I'm starting a mobile bike repair LLC with a buddy. We need about $15k for a van and tools. Bank says they'll approve it if we both sign personal guarantees. We're both 28, have about $10k in savings each, and this is our first real business. Is this a no-brainer or a trap? I keep going back and forth.
Would you personally guarantee a loan for a brand-new LLC?
No way. I guaranteed a $20k loan for my brother's LLC and ended up paying it back after the business folded. Never again
What are the loan terms? If it's a 3-year term at 8%, the monthly payment might be small enough that you can cover it from personal income if the business is slow. If it's 15% and a short term, that's a different story.
Honestly,for $15k, you might be better off putting it on a 0% intro credit card or getting a personal loan without tying it to the LLC. But I get it, sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do. Just make sure you and your buddy have a written agreement about what happens if one of you wants out.
Are you prepared to lose your $10k? If not, don't sign. Personal guarantee means the bank can come after your savings, your car, whatever. You're essentially betting your personal assets on the business.
I've done it twice. First time I got burned, second time it worked out. The difference difference was the second time I had a solid contract with my partner and we had a lawyer look at it. Also, we didn't need the loan to survive—we could have bootstrapped if we had to.
15k is small. If you can't save that up in a year, maybe the business Isn't ready.
Bike repair? Have you considered starting with just a trailer and your existing bikes? My cousin does mobile bike repair out of a cargo bike and he's killing it. Lower overhead.
I wouldn't. But I'm risk-averse. You're young, no kids? If you can afford to lose the Money and the time, go for it. If you have a family depending on you, think hard.
The bank is requiring a personal guarantee because the LLC has no credit history. That's standard. It doesn't mean the loan is a trap; it just means you're the collateral. Make sure you're both equally on the hook, and have a plan if one of you bails.
Thanks for the range of views. To answer a couple: the loan is 10% over 4 years, and we do have a written operating agreement that covers buyouts and death. We're leaning toward doing it but with a smaller amount—maybe $10k—and keeping our savings as a buffer. The cargo bike trailer idea is actually interesting; we could test the market first.