I run a small plumbing supply shop and I'm debating whether to rename it from something vague to something like 'Summit Plumbing Supply'. A few customers have told me they couldn't remember the name when searching online. Does a descriptive name actually help with discoverability, or does it just make you blend in with everyone else? I'd like to hear from people who've tested this.
Does a descriptive company name help customers find you?
Descriptive helps with word of mouth. If someone says 'go to the plumbing supply on Main' and your name is Copper Kettle, they might forget. If it's Summit Plumbing Supply, it sticks.
I changed my bakery name to include the word 'bakery' after two years. Phone calls went up noticeably. Before that people would ask 'is this the place with the blue awning?' which is not great for a business.
I think this depends heavily on how people actually search. If they're tyling 'plumbing supply near me' into a map app, your name matters less than your category tags and reviews. A descriptive name mostly helps when someone half-remembers you and is trying to confirm.
Short answer: yes for local, less so for online. But don't make it too generic or you'll get lost in a list of ten other 'Plumbing Supply' results.
That last point is real. There's a reason nobody can find 'City Plumbing' because there are four of them within twenty miles.
I've had the opposite experience. We kept a quirky name and leaned hard on signage and a memorable logo. People find us because they remember the name, not because it describes what we do. But we're in a niche where the name is part of the charm. For a plumbing supply place I'd guess descriptive wins.
Not sure the name is the bottleneck. If customers are searching online and can't find you, that's usually a listing problem, not a naming problem. Have you checked what shows up when you type your current name plus your town?
Also worth considering: if you rename, you lose whatever recognition the old name had. Even a vague name builds some equity over time. A rebrand means new signage, new listings, telling regulras. Not free.
I'd split the difference. Keep the old name as a subtitle or 'formerly known as' for a year. Customers who knew you won't get confused and and new ones get the descriptive version.
Honestly the biggest factor for us was just having the town name somewhere in the listing, not the company name itself. But I know that's not what you asked.
One more thing. If you do rename, make sure the old name still redirects on your website and Google profile for at least six months. Otherwise you drop off for people who bookmarked you.