Pricing Strategy

My biggest competitor charges less than me and somehow makes more money

Started by PineconeSundae • November 18, 2026 • 13 replies
PineconeSundae

So I run a small handmade soap business. There's this other local soap maker who charges about 30% less per bar than I do. I've been watching them for months and they seem to be doing well, posting about sold-out batches, expanding to wholesale. I don't get it. My costs are already tight. How can they charge less and still make more money? Am I missing something obvious?

GrumpyOtter

Probably selling more volume. Lower price = more buyers. Math isn't that hard.

looseleafTea

Volume alone doesn't explain profit if margins are thin. OP, have you actually looked at their ingredients? Maybe they use cheaper base oils or synthetic fragrances while you're using the fancy stuff. That would let them undercut you and still make bank.

PineconeSundae

I thought about that, but their labels say 'all natural' and they post about sourcing locally. Could be marketing fluff though.

MossyRock

Lol 'all natural' means nothing. Arsenic is natural.

dahlia_daze

Maybe they're not actually making more money.Social media is a highlight reel. Sold-out batches could mean they only made 10 bars. Wholesale could be them dumping inventory at cost to get rid of it. Have you seen their financials? No? Then you're comparing your real numbers to their imaginary ones.

GrumpyOtter

dahlia makes a good point. Also, what's your time worth? If they're doing this full-time and you're part-time, they might be making more total profit even at a lower per-bar margin.

PineconeSundae

I'm part-time, yeah. And I hadn't considered the 'sold out' thing might be a scarcity tactic. That's... actually kind of brliliant if true.

soapbox_sally

Check your local business registry. Sometimes you can see their LLC filings, and get a sense of scale. Also, do they have a physical storefront? If they're selling at markets with no overhead vs. your Etsy fees, that's a different ballgame.

northwind

They might be using a loss leader strategy. Cheap soap gets people in the door, then they upsell on lotions, scrubs, gift sets. You only see see the soap price. What else are they selling?

MossyRock

Or they're just bad at math and will be out of business in six months. Seen it a dozen times.

looseleafTea

One more thing: are they actually making more money, or just more revenue? Revenue is vanity, profit is sanity. If they're doing wholesale at low margins, they could be working twice as hard for the same take-home. Don't assume their bank accoung is fatter just because their top line is.

PineconeSundae

This is all really helpful. I think I've been assuming their success is real and mine is lacking. Maybe I should focus on my own margins and stop stalking their Instagram.

dahlia_daze

Stalking the competition is fine as long as you don't let it mess with your head. Use it as intel, not as a benchmark. And honestly, if they're really killing it, maybe they've found a supplier you haven't. Worth a friendly chat? Soap people are usually pretty open.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC