Legal

My accountant spotted an issue in the operating agreement

Started by midnight_cobbler • November 22, 2026 • 14 replies
midnight_cobbler

I run a tiny 3-person LLC (consulting). My accountant was going through our operating agreement for some year-end stuff and flagged something: the profit distribution section references an old version of our state's LLC act. She said it's not necessarily a disaster but could cause confusion if we ever have a dispute. Now I'm wondering if I need to pay a lawyer to redraft the whole thing or if this is something we can just fix with an amendment. Anyone dealt with this? I don't want to spend $2k on lawyer fees for a 3-person shop where we all get along.

grumpybeaver

Wait, your accountant reads your operating agreement? Mine just asks me for receipts in a shoebox and sighs.

Tessellate_88

If it's just a citation to an outdated statute, an amendment is probably fine. But the real question is whetnher the substance of the distribution clause still matches what you actually do. If the old act had different default rules, and your clause just says 'as per state law,' you might have an ambiguity. What does the clause actually say?

kaleidoscope_ranch

Following because I'm in a similar boat. Our OA was drafted in 2016 and I'm pretty sure it mentions a statute that got repealed. I've been ignoring it for three years.

grumpybeaver

Ignoring it for three years is basically the small business way.

NettleTea

Not a lawyer, but I've been through this. The cost isn't usually in the amendment itself—it's in the lawyer reviewing the whole document to make sure there aren't five other stale references. Ours had three. The amendment was cheap; the review was the bulk of the bill. Still cheaper than a fight later, though.

orbital_farmer

3-person shop where everyone gets along = the exact scenario where people skip fixing things and then someone gets divorced or moves states and suddenly the OA matters. Ask me how I know.

Tessellate_88

Also worth checking: does your OA have a severability clause? If so, a stale reference might just be severed and the rest stands. If not, an outdated provision could theoretically taint the distribution section. That's the kind of thing that makes a lawyer's eyes light up.

midnight_cobbler

I pulled the clause. It says distributions 'shall be made in accordance with the Act' and then cites the section number. The section number still exists but the content changed in 2019. So it's not a dead citation, it's a citation to a section that now says something different. Does that change things?

NettleTea

Yeah, that's a bit worse than a dead citation. A dead citation is obviously wrong. A live citation to changed Content is the kind of thing where a court has to guess whet her you meant old law or new law. I'd get it fixed. Doesn't have to be a full redraft though—a short amendment that restates the distribution mechanic explicitly (percentages, timing, etc.) and removes the incorporation-by-reference would probably do it.

grumpybeaver

OP i think the real takeaway here is your accountant is more thorough than most. Buy her a coffee.

kaleidoscope_ranch

This thread is making me want to dig out our OA. I don't even know where the PDF is. Probably on a laptop that won't turn on.

orbital_farmer

Honestly for a 3-person consulting LLC with no outside investors, the practical risk is low until it issn't. If you're all on the same page, have a lawyer draft a one-page amendment with the exact distribution language you want, have all three sign it, and staple it to the original. That's the middle path. Don't let the lawyer talk you into a $3k 'comprehensive restatement' unless there are other issues ngl.

midnight_cobbler

Yeah, I think the middle path makes sense. I'll ask the accountant if she flagged anything else while she was in there. Appreciate the input, especially the point about live citations vs dead ones—that distinction is what I was missing.

Tessellate_88

One more thing: if you do the amendment, make sure it's signed by all members, not just the managing member, even if your OA says the manager can amend. Distribution clauses are usually the one thing that needs unanimous consent. Learned that the hard way at a previous company.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC