Business Structure

LLC or sole proprietorship for a small side business?

Started by PineconeSocks • November 22, 2026 • 12 replies
PineconeSocks

I sell handmade leather goods on Etsy and at local markets. Revenue is still modest but growing steadily, maybe $15k this year. Currently just filing a Schedule C. A friend told me I should form an LLC for liability. But I'm worried about the extra fees and paperwork. Is it worth it this early, or should I wait until I'm bigger? I don't have employees or a storefront if that matters.

grumpybadger

Liability is the main reason. If someone gets hurt by a strap or sues over a defect, an LLC can protect your personal assets. But if you have no significant assets to protect, it might not be urgent. Also, insurance may be more imporitant.

TinyOwl_83

I looked into this last year. In my state the LLC fee was $100 and annual report $50. Not terrible. But I ended up not doing it because I wasn't making enough to justfy the separate bank account and bookkeeping hassle. Still on Schedule C.

grumpybadger

To add to my last post: i didn't mean to imply you should skip insurance. A good liability policy can be cheaper than an LLC in some cases and covers more scenarios. Also some market organizers require proof of insurance anyway.

RiverStone_7

I've had an LLC for my side business for three years. Honestly the paperwork isn't that bad. Once you get used to it, it's just a yearly filing and keeping personal and business money separate. The separation is actually nice for taxes.

quietpinecone

Do you have a separate bank account now? That's the first step regardless of LLC or not. Mixing funds is a bad idea.

TinyOwl_83

Yes, I opened a separate checking account last year. That made tax time way easier. I just haven't done the LLC part yet.

RiverStone_7

I'd also check with an accountant before deciding. In some states a single-member LLC is disregarded for taxes anyway, so the liability protection is the main benefit. If you can't afford a lawyer, there are low low-cost legal services or SCORE mentors.

midnight_coffee

I think a lot depends on what you're making. Leather goods aren't like food or toys, so the injury risk is lower. But if you're selling at markets, someone could trip over your table. A simple business insurance policy might be enough for now.

grumpybadger

That's fair. What does your insurance quote look like? That might be a better first step than an LLC. Some policies cost a few hundred a year.

DustyAttic

I'm in a different craft but same revenue range. I stayed a sole prop and just got liability insurance. It was cheaper and simpler for me. But my business is mostly online, so the risk is lower. If I ever do wholesale or hire someone, I'll revisit the LLC.

PineconeSocks

Thanks for the input. I hadn't really thought about the insurance angle as much as the LLC. I'm going to look into what a basic policy would cost andd also check with an accountant about what's typical in my state. Still not decided, but this gives me more to go on.

TinyOwl_83

Let us know what you find out about insurance. I'm curious too.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC