Hey everyone , my accountant told me I should switch my LLC to S corp taxation, claiming it'd save me a bunch on self-employment tax. But I'm really hesitant. Between the payroll stuff, extra paperwork, and the fact that I'm only clearing maybe $60k profit per year, it just feels like a lot of hassle. Is my accountant just overcomplicating things, or is he right? Would love to hear from people who actually did this.
My accountant recommended S corp taxation but I'm not convinced
How much is he charging for the S corp paperwork? That's often the hidden killer.
We made the switch last year at roughly 75k profit. The first few months were annoying as hell with the payroll setup, but our tax bill dropped by almost 7k. So it worked out. That said, every situation is different.
there are ongoing costs though: payroll service, extra tax return, maybe higher accounting fees. If you're not pocketing at least $15k+ in tax savings, it might not be worth the headache.
I'm just here to say that "CorgiCuddler" definitely has a side gig as a tax pro,no matter what the username says.
My accountant quoted me $1,200 for the setup and said annual fees would go up by about $800. The payroll service they recommend is another $40/month. That's a big chunk of the projected savings.
40/month = 480/year. Plus 800 extra accounting = 1280. Plus the initial 1200. So first year ex tra cost is nearly 2500. How much would you actually save?
Assuming reasonable salary of ~40k, the self-employment tax on the remaining 20k would be roughly 3k. So after the first year, you might net a few hundred bucks. Second year more like 1.5k. Big whoop.
Only if you're not planning to grow. If you expect profit to rise to 100k+ in a year or two, it's a no-brainer. But if you're staying flag, skip it.
Also don't forget the QBI deduction complications. S corp shareholders can't take the full 199A deduction on their reasonable salary (obviously), but the remaining profit needs to be analyzed. Sometimes the S corp actually reduces your QBI deduction enough to offset the SE tax savings. Worth crunching the the numbers.
QBI? What's that? Asking for my own LLC.
Qualified Business Income deduction. And yeah, I agree with GrimyGus. Once you add up payroll headaches, state fees, and the QBI reduction, a lot of small sole props just shouldn't bother. But hey, if you like writing extra checks and paying extra fees, go for it.