LLC

I want to use a Montana LLC for an online retail business

Started by PixelPirate87 • November 20, 2026 • 9 replies
PixelPirate87

I run a small online store selling handmade leather goods (mostly belts and wallets). I keep hearing about setting up an LLC in Montana to save on taxes and privacy, even if I live in California. Is this legit for an online retail business? I'm not trying to dodge anything, just want to know if it's worth the hassle. Any firsthand experience?

NovaQuill

Montana LLCs are popular for privacy because the state doesn't require member names to be public. But if you're running the business from California, you'll likely still have to register as a Foreign LLC there and pay CA taxes. The 'tax savings' are mostly a myth for retail.

GrumpyGus

Ah, the Montana LLC dream. Spoiler: it won't save you from California's Franchise Tax Board. They're like bloodhounds. But hey, at least you get a cool mailbox address.

TacoTuesday

I looked into this for my Etsy shop. The annual fees are low, but then you need a registered agent, and if you're in CA, you're looking at double paperwork. Not worth it unless you actually operate in Montana.

PixelPirate87

Thanks, that's what I suspected. I don't mind paying CA taxes, just wanted to see if there was any legit advantage. So basically it's only useful if I move to Montana or want a fancy address?

LunarEclipse

Privacy is the main draw, but for an online retail business, you might be better off with a Wyoming LLC if privacy is your goal. Montana's annual report is due every year, and you need a physical address there. Have you considered just using a virtual address in your own state?

SkepticalSue

I've had a Montana LLC for three years for my consulting biz. No issues, but I don't sell physical goods. The privacy is nice, but I still pay CA taxes. It's not a magic bullEt. Also, some payment processors might flag out-of-state LLCs, so check with Stripe or PayPal.

GrumpyGus

Just wait until you get a letter from the CA FTB asking why you're not filing. Fun times.

NovaQuill

Actually, if you're selling tangible goods, you might have nexus in multiple states anyway. Montana won't help you avoid sales tax. Honestly, for a small leather goods shop, an LLC in your home state is simpler and cheaper.

TacoTuesday

+1 to just forming in CA. I wasted $500 on a Montana LLC before realizing it was pointless for my situation. Live and learn


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC