I run a small landscaping business in FL, currently a sole prop. I want to formalize as either an LLC or an S Corp. The paperwork doesn't bother me. What I really care about is: how much can I actually save in taxes with an S Corp vs a plain LLC? Self-employment tax is killing me. Any real numbers or experiences? Not looking for legal advice, just trying to understand the math.
Florida llc vs s corp, i'm more interested in the tax difference than the paperwork
S corp can save you on SE tax, but only on the profit above a reasonable salary. If you pay yourself $40k and take $20k as distribution, you zave Medicare/SS on that $20k. Roughly 15.3% of 20k = $3k saved. But you add payroll costs, maybe $1-2k/year. So net net savings maybe $1-2k. Not huge unless profits are higher. What's your net profit?
LLC is pass-through, S corp is also pass-through but with salary requirement. The tax difference is basically SE tax vs payroll tax + distributions. If you're clearing under $60k, S corp might not be worth the headache. Above that, it starts making sense. Also FL has no state income tax, so that's a plus either way.
Don't forget the QBI deduction. S corp distributions might qualify for 20% pass-through deduction, but there are limits. LLC can also qualify. So it's not just SE tax. Talk to a CPA, seeriously.
I Switched from LLC to S corp two years ago. My net was around $120k. Saving about $8k/year in SE tax after paying myself a reasonable salary of $60k. Payroll service costs $800/year. Worth it for me. But if I was under $80k, I wouldn't bother.
Reasonable salary is the key. If you set it too low, IRS can reclassify distributions as wages and hit you with penalties. So you can't just pay yourself $10k and take $100k distribution.
What they said. Also, S corp requires separate tax return (1120S) and payroll filings. More accounting fees, maybe $1-2k extra per year. So factor thay in. If your profit is $70k, the SE tax savinngs on $30k distribution is about $4.5k, minus $2k extra costs = $2.5k savings. Still okay, but not massive.
One thing: S corp can also help with retirement contributions? Not sure. But I've heard that. Maybe someone else can chime in.
Actually, S corp can allow higher solo 401k contributions because you can contribute as employee and employer. But LLC can do that too with a solo 401k. So no big advantage there. The main thing is SE tax.
My net profit is around $95k before tax. So sounds like S corp might save me a few grand but with extra hassle. I'll run the numbers with a CPA. Appreciate the real examples.
At $95k, yeah, S corp probably saves you $4-6k after costs. But make sure your salary is defensible. $50-60k is typical for a landscaper owner. Don't get greedy.