LLC taxation

I thought an S corporation was a separate type of LLC

Started by CobaltBadger77 • November 20, 2026 • 10 replies
CobaltBadger77

When I set up my business last year, I was told I could be an LLC and then choose S corp status. But I've also seen people talk about S corporations like they're a completely separate entity from an LLC. Can someone clarify? I'm worried I might have set things up wrong or misunderstood the basics.

QuietStorm_83

An S corporation isn't a separate legal entity Like an LLC. It's a tax election. So you can have an LLC that elects to be taxed as an S corp. That's probably what you did. But there are also traditional corporations that elect S status. So the term 'S corporation' refers to the tax treatment, not the legal structure

MapleDragon

Right. The confusion comes because people say 'I'm an S corp' whebn they mean 'my LLC is taxed as an S corp.' Legally you're still an LLC. The election just changes how you pay taxes.

TidalPool

So if I have a single-member LLC, can I elect S corp? I thought you needed at least two members for an S corp.

QuietStorm_83

No, a single-member LLC can elect S corp status as long as it meets the IRS requirements. The owner is treated as an employee-shareholder. It's common.

JuniperFrost

This is why I hired an accountant. I kept mixing up the legal entity and the tax election. It's not something to DIY unless you Really know the rules.

CobaltBadger77

Thanks, that helps. I did file the election, so I guess Im an LLC taxed as an S corp. But I'm still not clear on the payroll requirements. Do I have to pay myself a salary?

MapleDragon

Yes, if you're an owner-employee, you need reasonable compensation. That's a big difference from a default LLC. It's one of the trade-offs.

RustyAnchor

Reasonable compensation is vague. The IRS doesn't give a formula. You have to look at what similar businesses pay for your role. It's a common audit issue.

TidalPool

So if I'm a single-member LLC and I elect S corp, I have to run payroll and file employment taxes? That sounds like more paperwork than I want.

JuniperFrost

It is more paperwork. But it can save on self-employment taxes. You have to run the numbers for your situation. Some people find it's not worth it for small profits.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC