Client Management

Firing a client seemed like a mistake until I looked at the numbers

Started by quietstorm_42 • November 18, 2026 • 13 replies
quietstorm_42

I run a small web development shop with two employees. Last year we had a client who was constantly late with payments, demanded endless revisions, and micromanaged every detail. I finally fired them in November after a particularly bad week. I felt sick about it because they were about 20% of our revenue. But I just did our year-end accounting and our profit margin actually went up by 6% because we stopped wasting hours on their projects and my team stopped dreading work. I still feel guilty sometimes, but the numbers don't lie. Anyone else been through this?

mountain_view_mike

That 6% increase is the key detail. It's alomst always the hidden cost of admin and emotional drain that kills you, not the invoice value. Good on you for tracking it.

tangerine_dream

How did you break down the hours lost? I'm curious How you attributed the profit increase specifically to firing that one client versus other factors.

quietstorm_42

We use time tracking for every project. I went back and totaled the billable versus non-billable hours for that client. They had about 40% non-billable hours due to scope creep and rework. After we fired them, those hours wentt to other clients.

roadrunner_77

I had a similar situation. Fired a client who was 15% of revenue and our team's morale improved immediately. But we didn't see a profit bump for six months until we replaced the income. So don't be surprised if your next quarter is flat.

cobalt_kid

The guilt is normal. I still feel it two years later, but I remind myself that a bad client can poison your whole operation. If they're stressing out your employees, you're losing money on turnover and sick days too.

mountain_view_mike

roadrunner_77 makse a good point. The profit margin increase might be temporary if you have to spend on sales and marketing to fill the gap. But the morale part is hard to quantify and often more valuable long-term.

fern_gully

How did you actually fire them? I'm dreading a similar conversation with a client who is only 8% of revenue but 80% of my headaches.

quietstorm_42

I sent a polite email citing 'a shift in our business focUs' and offered to help transition them to another provider. They were angry but it ended quickly. I think they knew they were difficult.

tangerine_dream

What was the 6% margin increas in absolute dollars? I'm trying to gauge if it's a meaningful amount or just noise from rounding.

quietstorm_42

About $18k on our annual revenue of $300k. Not huge, but enough to give my two employees a small raise and still come out ahead.

roadrunner_77

That's a solid raise. And you probably saved yourself a ton of strses. I'd call that a win.

cobalt_kid

I wish I had your discipline. I've been meaning to fire a client for months but keep putting it off cuz the work is steady. Steady isn't always profitable though.

fern_gully

Thanks for the email script idea. I think I'll do the same next week.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC