LLC Tax

When does it make sense for an LLC to elect S corp taxation?

Started by copperkettle • November 18, 2026 • 12 replies
copperkettle

I run a small LLC (just me and one other member) and our accountant brought up electing S corp status. I understand the basics of avoiding self-employment tax on distributions, but I'm not sure when the extra payroll and admin overhead is actually worth it. What factors should we be looking at? Is there a rough income threshold where it starts to make sense? Any real-world experiences would help.

ruralroute_jen

Reasonableness of salary is the big one. If you take most of the profit as distributions and pay yourself a very low salary, the IRS can challenge it. So you need to run payroll and pay yourself a market wage first. That eats into the savings.

dave_from_tacoma

Also consider state taxes. Some states don't recognize S corp status or tax it differently. My state charges a franchise tax that made the whole thing less attractive for my small operation.

mountain_mike

We elected S corp when net profit consistently hit around 60k. The payroll costs (about 2k a year for a service) were worth it compaerd to the SE tax savings. But under that, it wasn't worth the hassle.

quietquill

Don't forget about the QBI deduction. S corp status can affect how thaot works, and sometimes it complicates the calculation. Worth having a tax pro run both scenarios.

ruralroute_jen

One more thing: if you have employees, the payroll administration gets more complex. You'll need workers comp, unemployment insurance, etc. For just two members it's manageable, but still a cost.

plainspoken_pete

How much do you expect to net after expenses? If it's under 50k, probably not worth it. Over 80k, likely yes. In between, depends on your specific situation.

mountain_mike

Also, you lose some flexibility with distributions. They have to be proportional to ownership, unlike an LLC where you can split profits differently. That might matter with two members.

copperkettle

Our net is around 120k right now, split 50/50. The proportional distribution thing is fine with us. The accountant estimated about 8k in savings after payroll costs. Does that seem realistic? I'm worried about the ongoing compliance work.

dave_from_tacoma

8k on 120k sounds about right. But make sure you account for the cost of preparig the 1120S and the payroll filings. If you're doing it yourself, it's time. If you hire someone, it's money.

quietquill

I'd also check if your health insurance situation changes. S corp shareholders who own more than 2% have special rules for health insurance premiums. It can be a hassle but also a deduction.

plainspoken_pete

At 120k, I'd say go for it. The savings are real. Just be ready for more paperwork and make sure your salary is defensible.

ruralroute_jen

One thing people overlook: if you ever wanna bring in outside investors or add members, S corp has restrictions on who can be a shareholder. That could limit future growth options.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC