I own 50% of a small LLC in ND with one other member. We've been operating for about four years. He now wants out and wants me to buy his interest. We don't have an operating agreement, just the articles filed with the state. He's asking for what feels like a high number based on his own rough estimate. I want to make sure I do this right legally and financially. Where do I even start in North Dakota? Do I need a lawyer and an appraiser?
My North Dakota LLC partner wants to be bought out
No operating agreement is going to make this messy. In ND, without one, you fall back on state default rules, which can be vague. You absolutely should get a business lawyer involved before agreeing to anything.
Get an independent valuation. His rough estimate is probably based on emotion or future hopes, not actual books. A professional appraisal will give you a defensible number.
What kind of business is it? That matters a lot for valuation. If it's asset-heavy vs service-based, the approach is different.
It's a small manfacturing operation with some equipment and inventory. He thinks the equipment alone is worth a lot, but it's not new.
Agree with the lawyer advice. Also, check your articles of organization—sometimes there are provisions in there about member withdrawal, though probably not. The ND Secretary of State website has forms but they won't advis you.
One option is to have a neutral third party review the financials and propose a buyout price. If he won't agree to that, you might need to consider dissolution, but that's usually a last resort.
Be careful about tax implications. Buying out a partner can be structured as a sale of membership interest or as a redemption by the LLC. Each has different tax consequences for both of you. A CPA needs to be in the room.
Also, make sure you get a written agreement that includes indemnification and a release of claims. You don't want him coming back later for more.
How urgent is his exit? If he's desperate, you might have more leverage. But if he's willing to force a dissolution, that could hurt you both. It's a negotiation.
I went through something similar in Minnesota. The lawyer cost a few thousand but saved me from a bad deal. Worth every penny.
Do you have any loan covenants or contracts that require both members to sign? That could complicate a buyout. Check with your bank.
I hadn't thought about the bank. We do have a line of credit. I'll look into that. And yes, I'm going to call a lawyer this week. Thanks for the input.
One more thing: if you do a redemption, make sure the LLC has enough capital to pay him without jeopardizing operations. Sometimes a promissory note over time is better than a lump sum.
And document everything. Every conversation, every offer. It might seem excessive but it can protect you if things go sideways.