About 18 months ago I started a small online retail business with a friend. I put in $30k from a personal loan, he put in $5k plus some equipment worth maybe $2k. We never signed an operating agreement or anything formal, just a handshake deal that we'd split profits 50/50. Now that the business is doing okay, he says because we both run it day to day we should have equal ownership. I feel like my extra capital should mean a bigger share. We get along well and I don't want to blow up the friendship, but this feels unfair. Any advice?
I put in more money and my partner wants equal ownership
First thing, you need to figure out what the ownership split actually is under your state's default partnership rules. Without a written agreement, a lot of jurisdictions assume equal partnership regardless of capital contributions. That doesn't mean it's faur, but it might be the legal baseline you're working from. Worth a quick consult with a local attorney before you negotiate.
Ouch. Handshake deals always seem fine until they aren't. I agree with the above about checking the legal default but from a fairness standpoint I think you have a strong case. A 30k capital injection vs 7k is a pretty big gap. Maybe propose a structure where you get your capital back first before any profit split, and then ownership is closer to equal based on effort?
Was the $30k a loan to the business or an investment? That matters a lot. If it was a loan, you're a creditor, not necessariLy entitled to more equity. If it was equity, then yeah, you should have a bigger slice. Either way, this is why you write this stuff down.
The fact that he's asking for equal ownership means he probably views the day-to-day sweat as equal to the money. In some small businesses, that's a valid argument. But $30k vs $7k is not nothing. I wonder if there's a middle ground where you agree to equal ownership but with a preferred return or a higher distribution percentage until your capital is made whole.
This is why I'll never go into business with a friend. No offense intended, I just mean the emotional part makes it messy. good luck though.
I was in a similar spot years ago. We ended up doing a phased approach: I got 60% until my initial capital was returned, then it flipped to 50/50. It wasn't perfect but it kept the peace and recognized both the money and the work. You could also look at what your roles are now. Is he doing more of the daily operations than you? If so, maybe that tip the scale back toward equal.
To add to my earlier point, even if your state defaults to equal partnership, you can always agree to something different in writing now. The current situation is an opportunity to formalize things. Get an operating agreement drafted that spells out capital accounts, distributions, and what happens if one of you wants out. It'll cost a bit but way less than a lawsuit later.
The equipment he contributed is a bit of a wildcard. Was it truly worth $2k at fair market value? That might be a detail worth revisiting. Not trying to nitpick but it could affect the overall math.
I don't think you're wrong to feel this way. But I also think your partner isn't crazy for asking. The problem is you both may be anchoring on different things: you on the capital, him on the labor. I'd sit down and write out all contributions, financial and time-based, and see what a neutral third party would say. Maybe a business-savvy mentor or a mediator.
Thanks, everyone. I appreciate the different angles. The loan versus equity point is something I need to clarify for myself. And the phased ownership idea is interesting. We're going to talk this weekend weekend and I'm going to suggest we get something in writing regardless of what we decide. I'll update if anything changes.
Good plan. Also, don't let the conversation turn into a fight about who works harder. That's a trap. Keep it about the numbers and a structure you can both live with.