I registered my LLC in Ohio back in March under the name "Harborline Creative." I've been operating quietly, building a client base, not really advertising yet. Yesterday a friend sent me a link to a website and an Instagram account using the exact same name, offering similar design services, based in the same city. I checked the Ohio Secretary of State site and my registration is still active and no one else has filed under that name. I have no trademark registration, just the state LLC. What can I actually do here, and what should I do first? I'm not trying to be aggressive but I also don't want to lose the name I've been building.
Someone else started using my company name after I registered
State LLC registration doesn't give you exclusive rights to the name. It just means the state won't register another LLC with that exact name. It doesn't stop a sole proprietor or a differently structured business from using the same name. Your actual protection comes from trademark law, and that's based on who used the name first in commerce, not who registered first.
Did you actually use the name in commerce before they did? Like invoices, contracts, a website, anything with a date on it? That's going to matter more than the LLC filing date.
Yes, I have invomices going back to April, a signed client contract from May, and my domain was registered in March. I have a website but it's very minimal, basically a contact form and a portfolio. I haven't done any paid advertising.
Send a cease and desist letter. Not a threatening one, just a factual letter stating your prior use, your registration, and asking them to stop using the name. Many people in this situation genuinely didn't know and will change it. Use a lawyer if you can afford it, but a well-written letter from you is better than nothing.
A C&D is fine but be careful about the claims you make in it. If you imply you have a registered trademark when you don't, that can backfire. Stick to what you can prove: prior use in commerce, state registration, domain registration.
This is why I file a trademark. It's a few hundred dollars and it saves you from exactly this mess. Not helpful now I know, but for anyone reading.
I looked into a trademark after this happened. The filing fee is around $250-350 per class and I'd need to show use in commerce, which I can. My concern is the timeline. It takes months, and meanwhile they're actively using the name and building their own audience. Does filing give me any immediate leverage?
Filing gives you a filing date, which is what matters for priority. Once you file, you can put the ™ symbol next to your name immediately, and you can mention the pending application in your letter. It changes the tone. But it doesn't stop them from operating while it's pending. Only a court order does that, and that's expensive.
What does their website actually say? If they're presenting themselves as an established business with a history they don't have, that's a different issue. But if they just independently picked the same name, it's going to be hard to prove bad faith. Harborline Creative isn't a wildly distinctive name.
Their site says "serving the Midwest since 2024" which is technically true I guess. Their portfolio looks like it was made in the Last few months. I don't think they copied me deliberately, it's more that they didn't check. That's why I'm trying to figure out how to approach this wthout it becoming a fight.
Have you tried just emailing them? A polite email that says "hey, I noticed we're both using this name, I've been operating under it since March and have the state registration, would you be open to changing yours?" Sometimes that's all it takes. If they ignore it, then you escalate.
The problem with a polite email is it gives them notice. If they're smart, they'll immediately file their own trademark application on the name, and then you're in an opposition proceeding instead of a simple conversation. I wouldn't send anything informal without at least consulting a trademark attorney first. Even a 30-minute consultation is worth it here.
That's a real risk but I think it's overstated in most small business cases. The kind of person who starts a design business in the same city under a name they didn't check is not usually the kind of person who immediately races to the USPTO. But basementbird is right that a consultation is cheap compared to the alternatives. Also, document everything now. Screenshot their site, their social media, save your invoices and contracts with dates. If this does become a dispute you'll want a clean timeline.
I went through something similar. In my case I sent a letter myself, certified mail, stating my prior use and asking them to cease. They called me, we talked, and they changed their name. It cost me $12 for the certified mail. It doesn't always go that way but it's worth trying before you spend money on a lawyer. Just keep the letter factual and don't make legal threats you can't back up
I'm going to talk to a trademark attorney this week and get a clear picture of what my actual rights are before I contact them. I'll also start gathering the documentation. The certified mail idea is appealing because it creates a record without being aggressive. I'll update if anything develops.