LLC Partners

My Tennessee LLC partner wants to withdraw before we make a profit

Started by TacoTuesday77 • November 22, 2026 • 14 replies
TacoTuesday77

My business partner and I formed an LLC in Tennessee about a year and a half ago. We haven't turned a profit yet. Now he wants to withdraw his membership interest. Our operating agreement is pretty basic and doesn't spell out a buyout process. He wants his initial capital contribution back, but I don't think that's fair since we've used that money on expenses. I'm not sure what my options are. Do I have to buy him out? Can he just walk away? Any advice would help.

GrumpyOldCoder

You need to look at your operating agreement first. If it's silent on withdrawal, Tennessee's LLC Act might fill in the gaps. Generally, a member can withdraw but unless the agreement says otherwise, the LLC doesn't have to buy them out. His capital account might be what he gets, but that depends on the balance sheet.

MossyRock

I went through something similar in a different state.My partner left, and we ended up dissolving the LLC because we couldn't agree on a valuation. If you two can't come to terms, a dissolution might be the cleanest way out, but it means selling off assets and splitting whatever is left. Not ideal if you want to keep the business going.

CoffeeAndWires

Does your operating agreement say anything about dissociation? Even if it's basic, there might be a clause about what happens when a member leaves. If not, you might have to negotiate. He can't force you to buy him out unless there's a provision. But if he just leaves, he might still be entitled to distributions if the company ever makes a profit, unless you buy him out or dissolve.

JustHereForTheComments

This is why you always get a good operating agreement. Too late now though. Talk to a lawyer. Tennessee law can be trickky.

NashvilleBreeze

Im not a lawyer, but I've been in business for a while. Key queStion: what does the operating agreement say about withdrawals? If it's silent, the default rules in Tennessee might apply. Under the Tennessee LLC Act, a member can withdraw, but the LLC is not required to purchase their interest unless the agreement says so. However, the withdrawing member is entitled to receive the fair value of their interest as of the date of withdrawal. But that's often a negotiation. You might want to propose a payment plan or a percentage based on curremt assets. Also, check if there are any loans or debts in the LLC name that he's personally guaranteed. That could complicate things.

RustySpokes

Get a valuation done. That's the only way to know what his share is actually worth. If you can't afford to buy him out, you might have to bring in a new partner or dissolve.

LurkerNoMore

I agree with GrumpyOldCoder. The operating agreement is the first place to look. If it's silent, you need to read the Tennessee LLC Act. Tennessee Code Annotated Title 48, Chapter 249. There are default provisions about dissociation. But honestly, this is lawyer territory. A business attorney in Tennessee can tell you your rights and obligations. Don't try to DIY this.

MidnightSnack

Has he actually signed a withdrawal notice? If not, maybe you can talk him into staying on as a silent partner until the business turns a profit. Or offer to buy him out over time with a promissory note.

TacoTuesday77

Thanks everyone. I'll check the operating agreement again and look into the Tennessee statute. I think a lawyer is probably necessary at this point.

GrumpyOldCoder

Good call. Just be aware that if you can't agree, he can petition a court for dissolution. That might force your hand.

CoffeeAndWires

Another thing: if he withdraws, does he get to keep his membership interest? In some states, a withdrawing member becomes a mere assignee, losing voting rights but still entitled to distributions. That might be a workable solution if you want to keep him from meddling but avoid buying him out now.

MossyRock

That's true. It's called a financial rights only member. But it can get messy if the company starts making money and he wants his share. You might end up having to buy him out later at a higher price.

RustySpokes

You could also consider mediation. It's cheaper than litigation and can help you both come to a fair agreement.

JustHereForTheComments

Or you could just dissolve and start over. Sometimes that's the cleanest break.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC