Hiring

I hired too quickly and regretted it almost immediately

Started by quietstorm_84 • November 22, 2026 • 11 replies
quietstorm_84

Needed someone for front desk/socials. Interviewed one guy, seemed great, hired him same day. Day two he argued with a customer about our return policy and then posted from our business account about it. Just venting. Has anyone else moved too fast and regretted it?

foldersnob

Day two and already posting from the company account? That's almost impressive.

tuesday_after_five

Been there. Not quite that fast, but I once hired a guy because he was the only applicant who showed up in a button-down. Turned out to be a terrible reason.

notabot_justtired

Did you at least take away his login? If he's still got access to the socials, that's the fire, not the regret.

mossy_rock

This is why we do a paid trial shift. Not a full probation. One day, small task, you watch how they act when it's boring. Arguing with a customer is a personality trait, not a bad first day.

foldersnob

mossy_rock is right though, a trial shift tells you more than Three interviews. Also, a return policy argument is a weird thing to die on. That's like fighting over whether the sky is blue.

wrenandmartin

How small is the team? If it's just you and him, honestly just end it now. A bad hire on a tiny team poisons everything within two weeks. I learned that the hard way.

notabot_justtired

Also check your state's rules on firing within a Probation period. Some places you can just say it's not working, others you need documentation. Worth five minutes of Googling before you talk to him.

mossy_rock

Everyone's talking like this is a done deal. Has anyone here actually tried having a direct conversation first? Not every bad first week means you cut bait. Some people just need to hear "don't post from the business account."

sundriedheat

Honestly the social media post is the only part I'd take seriously. Return policy arguments happen. Posting about it publicly as the business? That's a judgment issue.

wrenandmartin

mossy_rock, sure, but he argued with a customer in front of who knows who and then went straight to the company account. That's a pattern, not a weak moment.

foldersnob

I still want to know what the customer said that set him off. Feels relevant.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC