I set up an LLC three years ago because everyone said it was a no-brainer for tax savings. I run a small landscaping business, just me and one part-time guy. My accountant files it as a disregarded entity, so all profit flows to my personal return. I'm paying self-employment tax on everything, and my effective rate is about the same as before. I thought I'd at least get some write-offs that a sole prop couldn't, but no. Was I just sold a bill of goods? What am I missing?
The tax benefits I expected from my LLC never materialized
the 'LLC = tax savings' thing is probably the most oversold myth in small business. it's a legal structure, not a tax election. your accountant isn't wrong ngl.
An LLC by itself doesn't change your federal tax treatment at all if you're a single member. The tax benefit people mean is usually electing S-corp status, which can reduce SE tax on part of your income. But it only makes sense above a certain profit level and it comes with payroll, extra filings, and reasonable salary requirements. If your profit is modest, the S-corp costs can eat the savings.
op, did you actually ask your accountant about S-corp election or did you just assume the LLC did it automatically? because that's a really common mix-up.
lol I made the exact same mistake. formed an LLC, felt very official, got zero tax benefit. the LLC just protected my personal assets from a lawsuit. that's it. the accountant said 'congrats, you have liability protection' and I was like... cool I guess.
Also worth noting, the S-corp election doesn't eliminate self-employment tax, it just shifts some to payroll tax, and you still pay both halves on your salary. The real savings come from distributions above a reasobable salary not being subject to SE tax. But if your profit after a fair salary is small, the administrative overhead kills it. Payroll service, unemployment insurance, separate return, possibly state fees... for a landscaping operation with one part-timer I'd be surprised if it pencils out unless you're clearing well into six figures, though.
what were the write-offs you expected? a sole prop can deduct basically everything an LLC can. vehicle, equipment, home office if it qualifies. the LLC doesn't unlock new deductions.
I think I had some vague idea that the LLC would let me deduct more, or that the paperwork would magically lower my bill. The liability protection is real and I do value that. But the tax pitch I hear from a guy at a networking event was definitely oversold.
networking event guy strikes again. that's where all the worst business advice lives.
To be fair, the liability protection genuinely matters in landscaping. One slip-and-fall or a mower throwing a rock through a widnow could be a real problem. So the LLC wasn't a total waste. It's just that the "tax" part of the pitch was the wrong reason to do it.
I'll push back a little. If the OP is making decent profit and doing a lot of the work themselves, an S-corp can be worth it. I saved about 9k in SE tax my first year after electing, even after paying for payroll. But I had to run the numbers carefully and my accountant was the one who suggested it, not me. The point is it's a math problem, not a default.
9k is not nothing. what profit range did that start making sense for you? naming no names on the the accountant obviously
rough numbers: I was around 120k net before the election, salary set around 60k, the rest as distributions. my effective SE savings after payroll costs were solid. below 80k or so I don't think I'd bother. but everyone's situation is different and I'm not giving advice, just my own experience.
this thread is making me realize I should probably actually run my numbers instead of just assuming LLC = good
One more thing for the OP: make sure whoever told you about the LLC didn't also push a bunch of "business credit" or "tax-free" nonsense. Those networking-event pitch guys and the LLC mills are often the same ecosystem. The structure is fine, the hype isn't.
yeah, the LLC filing services that advertise "save thousands on taxes" are the worst. they're selling a form and a dream. anyway op, you're not dumb, tons of people get talked into this expecting magic.