I'm helping my friend plan to start a small business together, but they're pushing back on having a written operating agreement or any documented split of responsibilities and profits. They keep saying we're friends and don't need paperwork. I'm worried about what happens if things go south or we disagree later. Has anyone dealt with this? How do I convince them without damaging the relationship?
My friend wants to form an LLC but refuses to put everything in writing
This is a huge red flag. Without a written agreement, your state's default LLC rules apply, which may not reflect what you both want. I'd insist on at least a basic operating agreement. If they refuse, consider whether you really want to go into business with them.
I've seen a friendship dissolve over exactly this. They started a landscaping LLC, no operating agreement, and when one wanted out, they argued for months over who owned what. Court was the only option, annd it cost them more than the business ever made. Please don't skip the paperwork.
What's their reason for refusing? Sometimes people are just intimidated by legal stuff. Maybe a simple one-page memo of understanding would feel less formal. But you still need something signed
Could you frame it as protecting both of you? Like, "I trust you, but I don't trust the future." That might appeal to their sense of fairness.
I agree with mountain_mama.The default rules in many states are messy. For example, in some states, if no operating agreement exists, profits are split equally regardless of capital contributions. That could be a problem if one of you puts in more money.
Have you considered getting a third party invol ved? A mediator or a business advisor might help explain why it's important without sounding like you're the one being difficult.
Thanks for the thoughts. I've tried explaining the risks, but they keep brushing it off. I'll bring up the idea of a simple memo and maybe a mediator. It's frustrating because I don't want to lose the friendship, but I also don't want to lose my investment.
That sounds like a plan. If they still refuse even a simple memo, you might need to reconsider going into business together. It's not just about trust; it's about clarity.
I'd also recommend consulting a lawyer in your state. They can explain the specific consequences of not having a written agreement. Sometimes hearing it from a professional makes a difference.
Maybe you could write down what you both agree on in an email and ask them to reply with confirmation. That's still a written record, even if it's not a formal document
An email might not hold up in court, but it's better than nothing. I'd still push for something signed.
Also, think about what you'll do if you can't agree. You might need to walk away. It's hard, but better now than after you've invested time and money.