I formed a Louisiana LLC with a friend about a year ago. We are both 50/50 members on the operating agreement. The problem is he has a full-time job and only put in some startup money. I run everything day-to-day, handle clients, do the books, all of it. It is starting to get under my skin that we split profits equally. Is there a standard way to restructure this without dissolving the LLC? I am not trying to screw him over but the current setup feels unfair.
My Louisiana LLC has two members but only one works in the business
You need to look at your operating agreement first.If it has a provision for adjusting distributions based on capital cntributions or services, you might be able to amend it. If not, you both have to agree to any change. Louisiana default rules under the LLC law are pretty rigid on equal voting unless the agreement says otherwise.
This is exactly why I never went 50/50 with someone who was not going to be active. It almost always leads to resentment.
What does your operating agreement say about member duties? If it is silent on the working member getting a salary or guaranteed payment, you are stuck unless he agrees to amend. I would propose a reasonable manager salary off the top before profit splits. That is usually easier for the passive member to swallow than changing ownership percentages.
A guaranteed payment for services is a clean way to handle this. It is taxed as ordinary income to you and deductible by the LLC. Then the remaining profit is split 50/50 Per the ownership. You still need his signature on an amended agreement though.
Redstick is right.I have seen that structure work. But be careful about how you document it. If you just start taking extra money without a written amendment, he could later claim it was an unauthorized distribution. Put it in writing and have both members sign.
How much money did he put in? If it was substantial startup capital, he might feel he already eaarned his share. Not saying that makes it fair long term but it explains his perspective.
Honestly, if he will not agree to a fair adjustment, your ootions are limited. You cannot unilaterally change the deal. You could dissolve and reform but that is messy and may trigger tax consequences. Have a direct conversation before doing anything drastic.
Also consider whether the LLC has made any formal tax elections. If you are taxed as a partnership, the guaranteed payment approach works. If you elected S corp, the analysis changes because you would need reasonable compensation for yourself as an employee.
To answer a couple of questions: he put in about 15k at formation. I put in 10k andd have been doing all the work since. No S corp election, we are just a default partnership for tax purposes. The operating agreement is very basic, just the standard fill-in-the-blank from the Secretary of State website. It does not address salaries or duties at all
That basic agreement is going to be a problem. With no duties clause and no distribution provision beyond equal splits, you are relying entirely on his goodwill to change anything. I would draft a proposed amendment and sit down with him. Frame it as protecting the business, not as a money grab.
One more thing. If you do a guaranteed payment, make sure it is reasonable for the work you do. If it is too high, the passive member could argue it is a disguised distribution. Document your hours and responsibilities so there is a clear basis for the number.
15k is not nothing but it is also not enough to justify permanent passive income while you do everything. I would be frustrated frustrated too.
Has he indicated he would be open to changing the structure? If he is reasonable, this is a two-hour conversation and a document. If he is not, you need to decide whether the business is worth the resentment.
I would also check whether your agreement has a buyout provision. If it does, and he is not willing to amend, that might be a cleaner path than dissolving. Either way, get a Louisiana business attorney to review the agreement before you propose anything. The fill-in-the-blank forms often have gaps that are not obvious until there is a dispute.