Taxes

My accountant suggested S corporation taxation and now I'm researching

Started by BlueLantern77 • November 16, 2026 • 14 replies
BlueLantern77

Met with my accountant last week. He thinks I should elect S corp status for my small business (I run a 2-person landscaping LLC). He says it could save us on self-employment taxes. Now I'm deep in research and honestly my head is spinning. Any of you actually done this? What should I be watching out for?

coffeeandjazz

The The SE tax savings are real but don't forget payroll admin costs. You have to pay yourself a 'reasonable salary' which means running payroll, filing 941s, etc. If your net profit isn't at least 60-70k the savings often get eaten by accountant and payroll fees.

GrumpyPanda

Lol my accountant suggested the same thing. Then quoted me $2k to set it up and $400/mo for payroll. Suddenly that 'savings' looked a lot smaller.

third_coast_kev

honestly the reasonable salary thing is the whoel ballgame. IRS has been cracking down on people taking $10k salary and $150k distributions.

Mildew

Two person LLC — how are you guys currently taxed as a partnership? Because that changes the math a bit. Each of you would need to be on payroll.

third_coast_kev

Yeah and with two owners you also have the whole 'reasonable comp' argument times two. More complexity.

sunset_fern

One thing nobody mentions — you lose some deductions and the QBI deduction gets weird. I'd run the numbers with a CPA who isn't the one selling you the setup, honestly. Get a second opinion, though.

coffeeandjazz

^^ this. Not sajying the accountant is wrong but they often have a referral relationship with payroll providers.

BiscuitsNGravy

I did it for my solo consulting gig, net was around $90k. Saved maybe $8k/yr after fees. Worth it for me. But landscaping with two owners and equipment? Different animal. Depreciation, vehicle stuff, workers comp... talk to someone who knows your industry.

GrumpyPanda

also worth mentioning: once you elect S corp you can't easily just flip back. There's a 5 year rule on re-electing. So if it doesn't work out you're kind of stuck.

Mildew

Wait is that true? I thought you could revoke with consent from shareholders. The 5 year thing is for re-electing after revocation I think ngl.

GrumpyPanda

Yeah that's what I meant, sorry. Revoke then you can't re-elect for 5 years. Still a pain.

vintage_vinyl

Just here to say my accountant also pushed this hard and I've been happy with it, three years running. But I'm one person, service business, low overhead. The reasonable salary number is the annoying part.

third_coast_kev

can someone explain why my accountant keeps saying 'distributiion' like it's a magic word. it's just money.

coffeeandjazz

It's not magic, it's just the portion that avoids payroll tax. But calling it a distribution doesn't change what it is — the IRS can recharacterize it if your salary is too low. So don't get cute.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC