Been running a small e-commerce thing for about 2 years now. It's actually profitable, which is wild to say. I have a business bank account, separate credit card, all that. But I never formed an LLC. I just keep filing taxes as a sole prop. Am I an idiot for not doing this yet? I keep seeing people say it's a no-brainer, but also that LLCs are overhyped for small operations. What's the actual risk here?
My business is making money but I'm still operating without an LLC
Not an idiot, but you're leaving yourself exposed. If someone sues you and wins, your personal assets could be on the line. LLC is cheap insurance.
Define 'making money'. If it's like $5k a month, yeah, go get the LLC. If it's $500 a month, the filing fees and annual reports might not be worth it yet. Also depends on your state. California’s LLC fee alone is $800 a year. That's a lot of profit to eat for a piece of paper.
Fair point. We're talking about $4-6k a month in profit righ now. And I'm in Texas, if that changes the math. I keep getting mixed signals from Google.
The 'cheap insurance' thing is sort of misleading. An LLC doesn't stop you from being sued personally if you personally did something negligent. It just separates the business entity from your personal assets. But if you're the only member and you don't follow formalities (like keeping meetings or separate records beyond just a bank account), a court can 'pierce the veil' and it's useless anyway. So you still need good contracts and insurance.
You have a separate bank account. That's honestly more than most people do before they start asking this question. In Texas the filing fee is only $300. Just do it. It's not a magic shield but it makes you look legit and it makes taxes slightly less painful if you ever want to elect S-corp later.
Yeah, at $5k/mo profit in Texas, the $300 is nothing. i was more warning against the guys making $500 a month in California trying to 'protect their brand' with a $800 annual fee. Different situation entirely.
lol "I'm an idiot for not doing this yet" no. You're an idiot for not realizing you could've been an S-corp this whole time if you're making that much. JK mostly. But seriously, talk to a CPA, not a forum. The fact you're profitable means you can afford an hour of a pro's time. They'll tell you exactly what structure saves you the most on self-employment tax.
Soda makes a good point. The LLC is the easy part. The tax election is where the real money is. Good problem to have though.
Honestly the veil-piercing thing is overblown for small single-member LLCs unless you're doing something super sketchy. The real benefit for most people is just sleeping better and not having your personal name on invoices. But yeah, Texas is easy.