So I run a small custom framing shop. Had this one lady, 'Karen' (not her real name, but you know), who came in three times demanding I change my deposit policy because she "might" not like the frame. I finally caved and made it refundable within 7 days for everyone. Now I've got people ordering custom mats and ghosting me. I feel like a complete idiot. Anyone else ever let a single pain-in-the-ass customer rewrite their whole rulebook?
I let one difficult customer change how I run things
lol 'Karen' in a framing shop. I bet she brought her own color swatches And a printout of Pinterest screenshots from 2014.
Yep. Been there. Had a guy complain so much about our 30-day return window that I extended it to 60. Big mistake. My shop isn't Amazon, and I don't know why I acted like it. Reverted it two months later. The lesson: one loud customer is not a trend. If it's just one person, it's a *them* problem. If it's ten, it's a *your praocess* problem.
This is why I stopped caving on policy. I just say "I understand, but that's the policy we have for everyone." They usually huff and leave. The ones who stay are usually fine.
I don't even understand custom framing deposits. You're literally cutting things. Of course it's not refundable. That customer is insane. OP, you got played by a pro. Next time ask yourself: 'would a reasonable person expect a custom-made item to be returnable?' No. No they wouldn't.
Yeah, I think the worst part is I *knew* it was a bad idea while I was doing it. I just wanted her to stop talking. Lesson learned, I guess.
The only thing more expensive than a bad policy is no policy. You just learned that the hard way. Don't beat yourself up too much though, first year of business is basically just a series of 'well that was stupid' moments.
Honestly, shoutout to you for admitting it. Most people wold just quietly change it back and pretend it never happened.
Don't worry, I'm changing it back. I just wanted to publicly humiliate myself first so I don't do it again.
I have a question. How many customers have actually taken advantage of the new refundable deposit? Like, is this a 2-person problem or a 20-person problem? Because if it's just 2 people, you might be overreacting.
Fair point. It's been 4 People in three weeks. But that's 4 people I did custom work for and then had to eat the cost on. So it feels like 4,000.
4 people in 3 weeks? That's actually a lot though. That's a trend.
Not to be that person, but if you make it refundable, people will treat it like a rental. It's human nature. The sunk cost of a non-refundable deposit is what makes them commit. It's not a coincidence that the 4 people who ghosted were the same ones who paid a refundable deposit.
The real trick is to offer a 'store credit only' refund. They feel like they're getting something back, and you keep the money in your ecosystem. It's the best of both worlds. I do that now and I've had zero complaints.
That's actua lly a clever idea. I might steal that.
Store credit is the way. They can't get cash back so they have to spend it on something else you sell. It's like a hostage situation but with frame mats.
Store credit! That's a genius idea. Saves my cash flow and makes them feel like they won. I'm going to try that first before just going full non-refundable. Thanks, Muffin_Thief!
Oh no, the 'I'm going to try that' follow-up. We've lost them, folks.