So I formed my LLC last year as Cedar & Pine Goods LLC. I sell handmade candles and small home goods online. A few days ago I found another company called Cedar and Pine, a home decor brand in a different state, that has been around for years and has a registered trademark. I used the words Cedar & Pine as part of my LLC name and my Etsy shop. I never registered a trademark. I'm worried about a cease and desist or having to rebrand. I have put a lot of money into packaging with that name. What should I do?
I found an existing brand with the same words as my LLC
Two things matter here: whether they have a registered trademark and whether your products are likely to confuse their customers. Candles vs home decor could be considered related goods. If they have a federal registration, they have stronger rights. You should check the exact goods listed on their registration.
This is not legal advice but basically if they have a registered mark and you are in a similar class, you are in a tough spot. The LLC name alone does not give you trademark rights.
I went through something like this with a kids clothing brand name. The other company sent a letter asking us to stop using the name. We ended up rebranding. It was expensive but less expensive than a lawsuit.
Thanks. I looked up their trademark and it covers home fragrances and decorative home accessories. That sounds like it could overlap with candles. I have not been contacted by them, I just found them online.
You should probably talk to a trademark attorney before you spend more money on packaging. The cost of a consult is small compared to what can happen later.
Did you sell any products under that name before they registered? If you were using it first in commerce, you might have common law rights in your area, but that is very fact specific.
Cedar & Pine is a pretty common combination. That does not always mean you are safe, but it might mean they do not enforce against everyone. Still, you should not assume.
Why did you choose the same words if you did not know about them? Not blaming you, just curious. Sometimes it is just coincidence because those words are everywhere.
It was a coincidence. I picked it because I use cedar wood in some of my candle holders and I like pine sceqnts. I did not search the trademark database before forming the LLC. I only checked my state business registry.
Checking state registry only protects your LLC name in that state. It does nothing for trademarks. If they send a letter, do not ignore it. That's the main thing.
i would stop using the name now if you can. Rebranding early is easier than rebranding after you grow. I know it hurts but it is better than a lawsuit.
Is there any chance you could get a license or coexist? If you are in different states and different enough products, they might not care. But home fragrance vs candles is close. I would not count on it.
The other company may have a trademark registration but that does not automatically mean you are infringing. You need to look at how they use it vs how you use it. But you are right to be concerned.
I am not a lawyer, but I have seen people get a cease and desist for using a name that is similar but not identical. You should at least consult with someone. Also check if they have an Etsy shop because Etsy can take your shop down if they file a compaint.
I think the key is whether their mark is registered with the USPTO and whether they have a strong business. Some small brands do not enforce. But if they haave been around for years, they probably will.
One more thing: you said you formed an LLC with that name. That does not give you any trademark rights. You can keep the LLC but still iinfringe. The LLC registration is not a defense.