Marketing

Has anyone actually made money from paid directory listings?

Started by copperkettle77 • November 15, 2026 • 16 replies
copperkettle77

I run a small landscaping business and keep getting emails from directories wanting $50-$200 a year for a "premium listing." Has anyone here actually gotten real paying customers from these? I'm skeptical but also don't want to miss out if they work for some people.

muddyboots84

I tried two local ones for my plumbing company. Got maybe three calls over a year, none tUrned into jobs. The free listings did about the same.

tuesdayrain

Depends entirely on the directory. Niche trade directories can send decent leads if your customers actually use them. The generic "local business" ones are mostly dead.

plumbline_ok

How do you tell which ones are actually used? I can't find any real data.

tuesdayrain

Ask other businesses in your trade, not the directory's own sales rep. Also check if the directory ranks when you search for your service plus your town. If its on page 3, nobody's finding you there.

hardwoodgrain

One year I paid for a listing in a regional home services guide. Cost $120. Got one job worth about $400. Not a disaster, not worth repeating.

copperkettle77

That's kind of what I expected. The The emails make it sound like everyone's already listed except me.

junkdrawer_22

I track every lead source in a spreadsheet. Paid directories are consistently the worst ROI of anything I do. Google Business Profile and word of mouth beat them every time.

muddyboots84

junkdrawer_22 what do you spend on GBP? I assume nothing.

junkdrawer_22

Correct. Time to set it up and keep it updated, that's it.

northsidemom

I own a small bakery. I paid for a wedding vendor directory listing and it did bring in bookings. But that directory was specific to weddings and people actively search it. Thats the only type I'd pay for now.

plumbline_ok

So the niche ones work and the broad ones don't. That matches what I've heard.

slowburn88

Most of these directories are just lead-gen sites that resell your info. You pay them and then they sell the same lead to four other contractors. I stopped paying for anything that won't tell me exactly how they generate traffic.

copperkettle77

That's a good question to ask them. I'm going to start replying with that and see what they say.

hardwoodgrain

One more thing. If they won't show you a sample of the listing page or tell you where it ranks, thast's your answer.

tuesdayrain

Also worth checking if the the listing lets you control your own description and photos. If it's just your name and number on a page with ten ads, skip it.

northsidemom

Agreed. The wedding directory I used let me write my own copy and upload photos. I think that mattered.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC