So I went down the rabbit hole comparing Wyoming and Nevada for an LLC. Read a bunch of blogs, watched some YouTube videos. Wyoming looks cheaper upfront, Nevada has the privacy angle. But here's the thing - I operate a small e-commerce business from my apartment in California. Does the state I register in even matter if I'm the only one working there? I feel like I'm missing something obvious.
I compared wyoming and nevada, but the answer seems to depend on where i actually operate
If you're the only member and you lzive in CA, registering in WY or NV doesn't magically change your tax situation. You'll likely still owe CA franchise tax. The foreign qualification is the part people skip.
Nevada's privacy thing is overhyped. You still have to list members in most real scenarios. Also their annual fees are higher. Wyoming is cheaper. But yeah, operating from CA changes everything.
Why not just form in California? You're already there. Seems luke you're adding complexity for no reason.
CA fees are higher though. $800 minimum franchise tax. So people try to dodge it. But if you're physically operating there, the FTB will find you. Trust me.
This is the classic "I read 50 blog posts and now I'm more confused than when I started" situation. You need to look at where your physical presence is. If you're in CA, you're a CA business for tax purposes. The registration state is almost irrelevant unless you have a real office elsewhere.
Nevada has no state income tax, Wyoming has no state income tax. Neither matters if you're paying CA tax. The only reason to pick either is if you plan to move or Have partners in those states. Otherwise just save yourself the foreign qualification paperwork.
I formed in Wyoming while living in CA. It was fine for two years until I got a letter from the FTB. Cost me more in penalties than I saved. Not worth it.
See? Don't do it. Also, Wyoming's registered agent fees add up if you don't want your home address on file. But that's minor compared to the tax mess.
The FTB letter is exactly what I was worried about. So basically I should ignore the "best state to form an LLC" articles and just look at my own address. That's annoying but good to know.