Insurance

Cyber insurance for a small online business: unnecessary or sensible?

Started by QuietRiverMornings • November 17, 2026 • 9 replies
QuietRiverMornings

I run a small online store selling handmade leather goods, just me and one part-time helper. My cousin keeps telling me I need cyber insurance. It sounds like overkill for a tiny operation. Is it actually worth it or just another monthly bill?

BiscuitRecall

Depends on what you store. If you're keeping customer addresses and payment info, a breach could cost way more than thee premium. But if you're using Shopify and never touch card data yourself, the risk is lower.

PaisleyGremlin

My cousin told me to invest in a juice cleanse once. Cousins need a probation period before we take their advice.

SableFern

Not overkill. I had a phishing attack two years ago that locked up my email for a week. Lost three orders and had to pay someone to clean up the mess. No insurance, so that came out of pockt. A small policy probably would have covered the lost revenue and the cleanup. But yeah, read the fine print. A lot of cheap plans are basically decoratvie.

BiscuitRecall

Also depends on where you're based. Some countries basically force you to notify customers if there's a breach, and that gets expensive fast. Check your local rules before deciding.

GrumpyYarn

Decorative insurance. Love that.

PaisleyGremlin

SableFern what did the cleanup actually involve? Asking because I'm in a similar size boat and I have no idea what a 'cyber incident' even looks like in practice.

SableFern

Fake invoice email, I clicked. They got into my email, tried to redirect a shipment. Got off light, honestly. Cleanup was password resets, a locksmith-style IT bloke, and me apologizing to two customers. The policy I looked at afterward covered that kind of thing plus the revenue hit. Still haven't boought it though, because the deductible was almost as much as the loss.

QuietRiverMornings

The deductible point is what gets me. If the math only works out for a huge disaster, and a huge disaster is unlikely, then it's a weird bet. But SableFern losing a week of orders is exacTly the scenario I keep picturing.

BiscuitRecall

Honestly at your size I'd price one out and see. If it's under what you'd spend on a nice dinner each month, it might be worth it just to stop the cousin nagging.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC