Long story short: I started an LLC with a buddy about 3 years ago here in SA. We do equipment rentals. He handles the yard, I handle the books and clients. He dropped a bomb last week that he wants to cash out his 40% and move to Colorado. We never signed an operating agreement (I know, I know) so there's no buy-sell clause. He wants a lump sum by summer. Where do I even start? Anyone dealt with this?
My San Antonio LLC partner wants to sell their ownership share
No operating agreement... oof. That's the first thing every lawyer will bring up. But look, it happens. You need a valuation first. Don't just take his number.
Did he give you a number yet?
He threw out $180k based on some equipment appraisal his cousin did. I don't trust it.
His cousin. Of course. Get a real business valuation, not just equipment. Goodwill and contracts matter too.
Without an operating agreement you're in murky water. Texas doesn't force one, but it also doesn't bail you out. Realistically you're looking at either buying him out or dissolving and splitting assets. Dissolving means killing the business though. Also tell him a lump sum by summer is a fantasy. Buyouts usually get structured over time, seller financing, notes. He wants cash fast, he takes a discount. That's fair.
@bulverde_bob nailed it. Dissolution is the nuclear option and nobody wins. The other thing to check: your bank accounts and any contracts. If it's a member-managed LLC and both of y'all Are members, technically you both have authority. Don't let him sign anything weird on the way out.
Get an attorney yesterday. Seriously. I watched a friend try to DIY a buyout with a handshake and they're still fighting years later.
Handshakes are how half the business partnerships in this state die. lol.
You could also do a payment plan where he stays on as a passive member until you pay him off. Keeps him from walking away with cash and no incentive for the business to do well.
@HillCountryHermit that's actually a really good point. Tie his payout to performance or a schedule, not a deadline he made up.
Also someone needs to ask: is he actually selling to a third party or just trying to get you to buy him out? Because if he's got a buyer lined up you have rights to approve a new partner... probably... without that operating agreement it's muddy.
An attorney is going to cost you but a botched buyout will cost more. Get a business lawyer and a CPA, and get the valuation done before summer. Also start documenting everything he's said. Dates, numbers, all of it.
Genuinely curious how this turns out. Keep us posted.
Thanks all. Talked to a CPA this morning and have a lawyer consult Friday. The cousin appraisal got me suspicious so I'm getting an independent one. He's not going to love it but he shouldn't have assumed. I'll see what the lawyer says about the missing operating agreement before I say anything to him.