Returns

A buyer returned a completely different item

Started by copperkettle88 • November 21, 2026 • 10 replies
copperkettle88

Sold a vintage brass compass on my store. Buyer requested a return claiming it was defective. I accepted and got the package today. Inside was a cheap plastic keychain compass. Completely different item. I have photos of what I sent and what I received. What are my options here? I already refunded them through the platform because I didn't want a dispute hit. Feeling pretty stupid now.

mothwing

That is rough. Did you refund before inspecting the return? Most platforms have a window to report Return fraud. Check your seller dashboard for a 'report buyer' or 'return issue' option. You might still be able to flag it even after refunding.

turnip_tuesday

I had something similar happen. Buyer sent back a used version of the same product. I opened a case with the platform and provided photos of the serial number on my original listing. They actually sided with me and reversed the refund. The key was the serial number matching. Do you have any unique identifiers on the compass?

copperkettle88

No serial number, unfortunately. It was an older piece. I do have high-res photos of the engraving on the back and the wear patterns on the brass. The keychain is obviously not it.

gravelpit_gary

This is why I stopped accepting returns on anything over a certain value.Not helpful I know. But the platform usually has a fraud reporting process. The problem is they may say you should have inspected before refunding. Still worth trying.

sableandpine

File a police report if the value is high enough. I know that sounds extreme but for return fraud it can help with platform appeals. Also report the buyer to the platform's trust and safety team directly, not just through the return flow.

mothwing

Agree with sableandpine. Also, check if the return label was generated by the platform or by you. If the platform issued the label, the weight recorded at the carrier might show a discrepancy. A brass compass weighs more than a plasti keychain. That could be evidence.

ferrous_wheel

Did the buyer have any prior return history?Some platforms flag serial returners. You may be able to request that info in a dispute. Otherwise, honestly, this might be a loss. Small sellers get burned by this all the time and platforms rarely claw back money from buyers.

turnip_tuesday

One more thing. If you used a payment processor outside the platform, you might have chargeback rights, but since you already refunded that ship has sailed. For next time, always inspect before refunding. It is a hard lesson.

copperkettle88

Thanks everyonne. I submitted a fraud report with the platform and attached all my photos. I will update if anything comes of it. Definitely will not refund before inspecting again.

gravelpit_gary

Good luck. Let us know how it goes. And take dtailed photos of every return before you open it next time. Even a video of the unboxing can help.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC