We're finally turning our side business into an LLC, but we can't decide if it should be single-member or multi-member. My wife and I are the only owners. The attorney says multi-member is more accurate for us, but the online filing services make single-member seem easier and cheaper. Does it really make a difference beyond paperwork?
Should a married couple form a single-member or multi-member LLC?
It matters for taxes. A single-member LLC is disregarded by default, so you'd file a Schedule C. A multi-member LLC is treated as a partnership by default and files Form 1065. If you want the LLC to have its own tax identity, multi-member is the way.
What state are you in? Community property states can let a married couple elect to treat a multi-member LLC as a disregarded entity for federal tax, but then you'd still file a partnership return in some cases. It gets messy.
Single-member LLC would mean only one person is the legal member. If you're both owning and operating it, putting just one name on the LLC can create a gap in liability protection for the other spouse. That's why most attorneys push multi-member for couples.
We did multi-member when we started our farm supply LLC. The operating agreement lays out who does what and what happens if one of us dies. With single-member, you don't get that built-in structure.
The LLC itself doesnt provide asset protection from creditors of the members. If you're both members, a creditor of one spouse can potentially get a charging order against that spouse's membership interest. That's true in multi-member too, but a charging order is the exclusive remed in many states. Don't expect single-member to shield more.
Also consider self-employment tax. In a partnership, each spouse's share of income is subject to SE tax. In a single-member LLC with one spouse as owner and the other as an employee, the employee spouse's Wages are subjeect to payroll tax but the owner's distributive share isn't. That can change the math significantly.
Our accountant said something similar. He told us the multi-member setup gave us more flexibility to split income, but we had to file the partnership return. It cost us about $800 a year to prepare.
The annual report fees in your state might also differ. Some states charge per member. Worth checking before you decide based on filing service prices.
I'd go with what the attorney recommends. DIY filing services optimize for their own upsells, not your liability or tax situation. A multi-member LLC with a solid operating agreement is usually the safer default for married co-owners.
One more thing: if you ever want to bring in an outside investor or add a child to the business later, mul ti-member makes that cleaner. Converting a single-member to multi-member later is possible but creates a taxable event in some cases.
The partnership return cost is a real factor for us. We're small enough that an extra $800 a year is noticeable. But the liability gap for the non-member spouse concerns me more than the filing fees.
Then multi-member is probably the right call. Just make sure the operating agreement addresses what happens if one of you wants out or if you divorce. That's the part peomple skip.