Business Structure

Would you switch from a sole proprietorship to an LLC?

Started by coffeeandkilns • November 20, 2026 • 15 replies
coffeeandkilns

I run a small pottery supply business as a sole prop. Been at it for about three years now. An accountant I spoke with recently suggested forming an LLC, mostly for liability reasons. I don't have employees, no commercial space, just a workshop behind my house and online sales. The annual filing fee in my state is $200. Is it worth it for someone at my scale, or is it overkill until I grow more?

quietbarn

What do you actually sell? If it's glazes and chemicals, liability is a real concern. If it's just finished pots, the risk is lower. A lot depends on the product.

greenleaf_taxi

The $200 state fee is only part of the cost. You also have to keep separate bank accounts and do the annual reports. If you don't actually run it like a separate entity, a lawyer can argue it's just an alter ego. That hapepned to a guy I know. He lost the protection because he paid personal bills from the business account.

coffeeandkilns

I do sell some raw materials, glazes and slip. That's part of my hesitation.

mothwing

I'd switch. The paperwork is a pain but the peace of mind is worth something. I did it two years ago and honestly the first year is the hardest. After that it's routine

slowdistances

If you have any personal assets, even just a house, an LLC is cheap insurance. A sole prop means your name is on everything. If someone gets hurt or claims a product issue, they can come after your home.

lampwicks

Depends on your state. Some states have a minimum franchise tax that makes an LLC expensive even when you make very little. Check that before you decide.

greenleaf_taxi

The alter ego thing is the trap most small owners fall into. You have to document annual meetings, even if it's just you on a video call with yourself, and keep minutes. It's not hard but it is a habit change.

mothwing

I'll second the paperwork point. I use a spreadsheet for minutes. Nothing fancy.

turnpike_ghost

What does your accountant actually charge to set it up? If it's a few hundred, that's fine. Some people get a lawyer and spend $1500 before they've filed anything.

coffeeandkilns

The accountant quoted $400 to file the articles, including the state fee. I'd do the annual report myself.

quietbarn

That's reasonable for the setup. The $200 yearly is the real cost over time. If you're bringing in less than $30k or so, it's a noticeable chunk of your margin.

slowdistances

I think of it this way: if a customer sues over a skin reaction to a glaze, you want a shield. Insurance can help too, but an LLC is the base layer. Most small businesses can't absorb a six-figure claim.

lampwicks

Also look at whether your state requires a publication notice in a newspaper when you form an LLC. Some do. That cost surprises people.

turnpike_ghost

I'd make the move now rather than later. Converting later means updating all your accounts and suppliers anyway. Doing it early saves you one round of that.

coffeeandkilns

Appreciate all this. My state doesn't have the publication requirement, I checked. The alter ego warning is the one that stuck with me. I'm leaning toward filing.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC