I see so many people on here and other forums saying "first sale? form an LLC immediately!" and I just don't buy it. Unless you're making serious money or have real liability exposure, an LLC is overkill. You can just be a sole prop and pay taxes on your 1099 income. The amount of money people waste on registered agent fees and state filings for a $200/month side hustle is wild. Change my mind.
Unpopular opinion: you don't need an llc just because you started making money online
I agree, but with a caveat. For digital products with no physical risk, sole prop is fine. But if you're selling anything that could hurt someone (supplements, tools, etc.), you're playing with fire.
Not to mention, you can just get a liability insurance policy for a fraction of the cost of an LLC if you're worried. But most people don't even need that.
I fell for the hype. Formed an LLC in 2021 for my Etsy shop. Made $800 that year and paid $300 in LLC fees. So yeah, you're right.
This is bad advice for anyone who might get sued. LLC protection is cheap compared to a lawsuit. But sure, gamble with your personal assets.
@grimbo LLCs don't protect you from personal liability for your your own negligence or fraud. And if you're a one-person LLC, courts can pierce the veil easily if you don't keep separate finances. So for a small side hustle, it's often not the magic shield people think.
Eh, I look at it differently. An LLC makes you look more professional to clients. When I hire freelancers, I'm more likely to trust one with an LLC. Maybe that's just me.
No, it's not just you. But that "professional" look costs money. If your clients are consumers, they don't care. If they're businesses, they might. B2B vs B2C matters.
I've been a sole prop for 6 years making 6 figures. Never had an issue. The LLC obsession on this sub is bizarre.
Six figures? Okay but that's a totally different situation. The OP is talking about people making $200 a month. Huge difference.
The real question: does forming an LLC actually change your taxes? For most small sole props, no. You're still taxed as a pass-through. Only benefit is self-employment tax with an S-corp, but that's for higher earners.
I think the fearmongering comes from liability. But honestly, if you're selling a PDF guide, what's the worst that happens? Someone says you gave bad advice? You're not going to lose your house over that.
@moonboots Until someone sues for deceptive trade practices or copyright infringement. But yeah, the odds are low. Still, an LLC is cheap insurance. Why risk it?
I get the insurance angle, but for a lot of people it's not cheap insurance. It's $50-$500 a year plus paperwork, plus anNual reports. And if you're not making much, that's a real burden. @cloudshouter nailed the real protection recipe: separate finances and maybe an umbrella policy.
Honestly, the most important thing is to keep your business money separate, whether it's a separate bank account or just a spreadsheet. Commingling is what gets sole props in trouble more often than lack of an LLC.
I'm still stuck on the "look professional" thing. Maybe it's because I work in an industry where everyone has an LLC. But I can see how it's a waste for a hobby-level income.
Also, some states are cheap ($50) and some are expensive (CA $800). So it's very location-dependent. Someone in CA making $500/year definitely shouldn't form an LLC.