I used to do leatherworking as a way to unwind. Last year I started selling belts and wallets. At first it was great, but now every time I sit at my bench I feel this pressure to produce and count hours. I haven't made anything just for myself in months. It's like the joy got replaced by deadlines and customer messages. Has anyone dealt with this? I'm thinking of shutting down the shop but I feel like a quitter.
Turning a hobby into a business nearly ruined the hobby
I went through the same thing with knitting. Once I opened an Etsy shop, every stitch felt like it had a dollar value attached. What helped was setting strict hours, like I only do orders on Tuesday and Thursday mornings. The rest of the week is mine. It took a while to stop feeling guilty about saying no to custom requests.
Not a quitter. Realizing that something isn't working is not quitting. You just found out the hard way that monetizing a hobby can change its nature. Nothing wrong with going back to making things for the love of it. There are other ways to earn money that don't drain your creative well.
This is why I keep my crafting and my income separate. I tried selling my ceramics for a year and it almost killed my passion. Now I just give stuff to friends or keep it. The pressure to make back material costs was too much.
I tyhink the key is to not let the business own you. Can you raise your prices so you don't need as many orders? That might make it bearable again.
Honestly, I think the feeling of being a quitter is the worst part. We're so conditioned to think we have to monetize everything. But a hobby is allowed to just be a hobby. It's allowed to be unproductive and private. You don't owe anyone a business. Once I realized that, it was easier to step back.
i run a small woodworking business and I had to puut boundaries in place. No custom orders, only what I feel like building. I know that's not possible for everyone, but it saved my sanity. Maybe you could switch to a model where you only sell ready-made items and ignore messages for a few days?
The customer messages are the worst. People asking for updates, sending you their inspiration photos, expecting you to be a mind reader. It adds so much invisible labor that nobody pays for. I don't blame you for wanting out.
Just to follow up on what wanderingpotter said, the idea that a hobby must be productive is a myth. I knew a guy who turned his love of fishing into a charter business and now he hates being on the water. It's a common trap.