Met with a CPA last month who made the S corp election sound like a no-brainer. Lower self-employment tax, blah blah. Finally sat down and ran the numbers including payroll service fees, the extra 1120-S prep, franchise tax in my state, and the fact that I'd need to pay myself a "reasonable salary" which eats most of the savings. The projected benefit for my solo LLC is like $1,800 a year before I account for my own time. Feel like I got sold a brochure, not a plan. Anyone else run the math and just... not do it?
The S corp election sounded great until I calculated the costs
1800 is still 1800? Unless your time is worth more than that doing the extra admin.
The "reasonable salary" thing is what gets people. Everyone thinks they can pay themselves 20k, and take the rest as distributions until the IRS decides otherwise. Your CPA was probably being conservative which is why the savings shrank.
Also franchise tax varies wildly. In CA it's like 800 minimum just to exist as an S corp. OP didn't say the state.
I did it for three years and went back to LLC. The payroll filings, the quarterly stuff, my bookkeeper charging more... it wasn't the dollar cost so much as the mental load. Every March I was stressed about the 1120-S. Went back to schedule C and honestly I sleep better. The tax savings weren't life-changing.
Counterpoint: if you're clearing 150k+ net the math flips pretty fast. Sounds like OP might be smaller. What's your ballpark net?
lol at "got sold a brochure." accurate description of like 90% of tax strategy advice aimed at small biz.
The other thing nobody mentions is exit costs. Dissolving an S corp, dealing with the final return, possible built-in gains stuff down the road. It's not free to undo either.
Net's around 85k most years,which is exactly the zone where it's marginal. And yeah the undo cost is real, that's what's keeping me from just trying it for a year.