My brother and I have run a small landscaping operation for about three years, and last month we finally sat down with a lawyer to formalize things. The whole process got complicated fast. His read was that if we ever want to take on an investor or partner, the default LLC setup we had in mind could become a headache. Now I'm second-guessing whether we should just stay informal, or restructure before we even get off the ground. Anyone been through this?
The LLC seemed simpler until we started discussing outside investment
Restructure before you get off the ground. It's way cheaper than doing it after you have revenue, contracts, and a co-owner with opinions.
What did the lawyer actually say was the problem? "Headache" is doing a lot of work in that sentence.
Something about the operating agreement needing to spell out how new members get added and how profits get split if someone buys in. Our original plan was basically a handshake with a document attached.
Handshake LLC. Love it. That's how you end up on a podcast about lawsuits.
It's not really about the LLC being hard, it's about the operating agreement. You can keep the LLC and just fix the agreement so a future investor scenario isn't a nightmare. Have the lawyer draft the admission of new members clause, though.
Also worth asking whether an investor would even want an LLC vs converting to a corp. Some of them get weird about it.
Stay informal, save the money, and revisit when someone waves a check at you. You've been running three years without it blowIng up.
That's terrible advice for a business with two owners, though. What happens if your brother gets married and his spouse has opinions about the business?
That's fair. I was thinking about the investor angle, not the brother angle.
Yeah the brother angle is real. We're both married. Nobody's worried now but i could see it getting weird in five years.
Honestly the whole "investor" conversation is premature if you haven't even got the operating agreement nailed down. Do that first, it's the boring part but it's the part that matters.
Counterpoint: some of the most successful small businesses I know are technicall a mess on paper and everyone's still friends. Not recommending it, just observing.
Survivorship bias. The ones that failed aren't posting about it.
Get the operating agreement done, ask the lawyer to specifically address new member admission and buyout, and stop worrying about the investor part until there's an actual investor.