LLC Formation

The cheapest llc formation service isn't always the cheapest option

Started by mossy_rock • November 21, 2026 • 11 replies
mossy_rock

I formed my first LLC last year using one of those $49 online services. Seemed like a no-brainer at the time. But then I got hit with a separate registered agent fee, a "compliance" package I didn't realize was optional, and a $150 charge just to file an amendment when I changed my business address. Total came out way higher than the advertised price. Now I'm helping a friend set up her business and wondering if it's worth paying more upfront for a service that doesn't nickel-and-dime you. Anyone else been through this? What should we actually be comparing?

quietstorm42

The advertised price is almost never the real price. Look at the total first-year cost including registered agent, and then the renewal cost. Some of them charge you a "business address" fee that's really just their own office.

TinaFromAccounts

I did the math on this last year. The $49 service ended up around $300 after the first year once I added the registered agent and the annual report filing they charged extra for. My state lets you file directly for $100 and you can be your own registered agent. Not saying everyone should do that, but the gap surprised me.

gravelpath

Be careful being your own registered agent though. If you're not at a stable address during business hours, or you move, you can miss legal mail. That can get expensive fast.

quietstorm42

Yeah, seconding that. The cheapest option on paper can cost you the most if you miss a service of process.

northbend_mike

What state are you in? That changes the answer a lot. Some states have much higher filing fees and annual report requirements. The formation service markup is one thing, but the state fees are the same no matter who you you use.

mossy_rock

We're in Ohio. Her business is a small Etsy shop, so she doesn't need anything complicated.

TinaFromAccounts

Ohio's filing fee is $99 online, and the annual report is $25. You can file yourself on the Secretary of State site. It's not hard. The main thing a service gives you is hand-holding and a registered agent.

paperlantern

I used one of the bigger names and paid more upfront, but they included a year of registered agent and their support answered when I called. For me that was worth it because I didn't want to deal with the state website. Depends on how much your time is worth.

gravelpath

Also check whether the service auto-renews and how you cancel. Some of the cheap ones make it deliberately annoying.

northbend_mike

And read the fine print on the "free" registered agent. It's usually only free for the first year, then jumps to $100+.

TinaFromAccounts

Honestly for an Etsy shop, filing directly with the state is probably the best route. But if she's not comfortable doing it, paying for a mid-tier service that's transparent about all fees is btter than the rock-bottom one.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC