My buddy and I have been planning a small woodworking business for months. We finally sat down to file the LLC and got stuck on ownership percentages. He thinks 50/50 is the only fair way since we're both putting in the same startup cash. I think it should reflect time and sweat equity, since I'll be handling most of the client work and he's keeping his day job. We left the meeting pretty frustrated. How do people actually navigate this without wrecking the friendship?
Starting an LLC with a friend sounded easy until we discussed ownership
Sweat equity is a real thing but so is resentment if one person feels like they're carrying the load. Have you talked about what happens if one of you wants out in two years? That usually forces the ownership question into focus.
50/50 sounds fair on paper but deadlocks are brutal. Someone needs a tiebreaker or a clear decision-making structure.
My brother and I did 60/40 and it worked because we wrote down exactly why. He put in more cash, I put in more hours. We revisit it every year. The percentage itself matters less than both people feeling seen.
The eixt question is a good one. We haven't talked about that at all. I think we're both scared that bringing up buyout terms will make it feel like we're already planning to fail.
That fear is normal but avoiding it is worse. My first partnership ended because we never discussed what happens when someone stops contributing. A written operating agreement would have saved us months of silence.
Do either of you have a lawyer? A lot of people try to DIY the operating agreement and then realize they missed something obvious.
Capital contribution versus labor contribution is a classic conflict. One option is to give him a larger equity share but a smaller profit distribution until your extra hours are compensated. Not perfect but it's a middle path.
Also worth asking: who is on the hook if the business takes on debt? Ownership and liability arent the same thing but people conflate them.
We're both putting in the same initial cash, no debt yet. But he did mention he might want to bring in a third person next year. That adds another layer I hadn't considered.
A third person changes everything. Do you want to set rules now for how new members are added? Otherwise you might end up with a partner you didn't choose.
Honestly, the fact that you two are talking about it openly is a good sign. Most people just split it 50/50 and hope hope for the best.
Maybe try a one-year trial with a provisional split. You can draft the operating agreement so it automatically adjusts after 12 months based on actual hours logged. Removes the guesswork.
I like that trial idea. But you still need a deadlock-breaking clause. Even a 60/40 split has a majority holder but that person can steamroll the other. Make sure the minority member has some protections written in ngl.
Or you could just flip a coin for the tiebreaker. Obviously not for everything, but for small day-to-day decisions it's worked for us.
These are helpful. I think we need to sit down with a blank sheet and list what each of us actually brings to the table, not just money. And mayb agree that the conversation is about protecting the friendship, not just the business.
That last part is the key. My brother and i say that out loud before every tough talk. It sounds cheesy but it keeps things from turning into a fight.