I make printable planners and some lightweight notion templates. Currently on Etsy but the fees and the sheer number of similar listings are killing me. Thinking about building my own site with Gumroad or Lemon Squeezy. Anyone here moved off a marketplace? Did you keep both or go all in? Worried about traffic mostly.
Selling digital products through my own website instead of a marketplace
Traffic is the whole ballgame. Marketplace brings the eyeballs, your site brings brings the margin. Most people I know run both for at least a year before even thinking about cutting the cord.
Gumroad fees are not exaactly tiny either. Have you actually run the numbers vs Etsy? Sometimes the difference is smaller than it feels.
I moved my font shop off Creative Market two years ago. Revenue dropped maybe 30% for the first four months, then climbed back past the old number once I got serious about email. The list is the asset. Marketplace customers are not yours.
Yeah I have about 900 Etsy buyers and zero of them are on an email list because Etsy makes that awkward. That part stings.
Just start the site and keep Etsy running. Put a little card in every Etsy package pointing to your site for "free updates" or whatever. Slow bleed, no drama.
Lemon Squeezy handles VAT for you which saved me a headache. Gumroad does too but their checkout feels clunky on mobile. Worth testing both before committing.
Also nobody talks about this but having your own site means you eat the refund disputes and the "where is my download" emails. Marketplace support is invisible labor you're currently not paying for.
honestly the number of people who can't find a download link in an email is staggering. prepa re yourself.
The support angle is the one I keep underestimating. Might just do both and treat the site as the long game rather than a replacement.