LLC Structure

One LLC or three separate companies for different activities?

Started by CopperKettle77 • November 13, 2026 • 11 replies
CopperKettle77

I run a small handyman business and also sell vintage tools online. Thinking about starting a third thing (maybe a rental side). Should I put everything under one LLC or create separate companies? My accountant says one is simpler but I'm worried about liability. Any real-world experience?

MossyLog

Separate LLCs mean separate tax returns, separate books, separate bank accounts. That's a lot of admin for a small operation. Unless one activity Has serious liability risk, I'd keep it simple.

TangoFoxtrot

Liability is the whole point. Handyman work can get sued. Selling tools online, less so. Rental? Depends. You could do one LLC with a DBA for each, but that doesn't shield you from cross-claims.

jenny_from_the_block

My husband had one LLC for his landscaping and a separate one for snow removal. It was a pain at tax time. He eventually merged them because the accountant charged double. Just my two cents.

GrumpyGus

Three companies means three sets of annual fees, three registered agents, three everything. Unless you're making bank, that's death by paperwork.

spindrift_22

What kind of rental? If it's equipment rental, that's a different insurance profile. Might be worth a separate entity if you're storing expensive stuff. But honestly, talk to a lawyer, not us yahoos.

TangoFoxtrot

Also, if you commingle funds between activities under one LLC, a court could pierce the veil anway. So you'd need to keep separate books regardless. Might as well separate entities if you're doing that.

MossyLog

That's jot entirely true. You can have one LLC with multiple divisions and separate bookkeeping. Piercing the veil is about fraud or commingling personal and business, not inter-division. But yes, separate books are key.

PixelPusher

i have three LLCs for three e-commerce brands. Total overkill. I spend more time on compliance than selling. Don't be me.

GrumpyGus

What's the third activity again? Rental of what? If it's just a side husle, one LLC is fine. If you're renting heavy equipment, maybe not.

spindrift_22

Also consider an umbrella insurance policy. Cheaper than extra LLCs for most small risks.

jenny_from_the_block

I'd start with one and only spl it if the rental takes off. But what do I know, I'm still using a shoebox for receipts.

Join the conversation

Log in or register to reply to this discussion.

🚀 Start Your Free LLC