Our LLC is registered in Vermont. Two members. I handle most of the operations, bookkeeping, and client calls. My partner does maybe 10 hours per week on product development. Our operating agreement is silent on unequal contributions. How do we handle profit splits and decision-making without causing resentment? We never formalized anything beyond 50/50 ownership.
My Vermont LLC has two owners who contribute different amounts of work
The operating agreement being silent is your main problem. Vermont's default LLC statute will split profits equally regardless of work if you haven't specified otherwise. You need to amend it with a clear compensation structure.
how bad is the resentment already? if it's just starting you have time. if it's been building for months, a written amendment won't fix the feelings part.
I've seen this before. The 50/50 ownership with unequal work usually leads to one person feeling like an employee. Consider a member compensation clause that pays a reasonable salary for the extra work before profit distributions. That way ownerrship stays 50/50 on paper but actual pay reflects effort.
brambleandpine has a point. Have you two actually talked about this directly or is it just simmering?
We've talked around it. Never sat down with numbers. I think we both avoid the topic because we don't want to seem greedy.
The numbers are the easy part. You can track hoUrs and compare market rates for what each of you does. The hard part is the conversation. But once you have a spreadsheet it becomes less personal.
Is the 10 hours per week product development actually valuable? Sometimes the person doing less hours is doing the higher-leverage work. Worth thinking about before you assume unequal contribution means unequal value
east_putney_gal that's fair but if the ops person is doing bookkeeping and client calls they're keeping the lights on. That's not low-leverage.
Operating agreement amendment. Do it now. Include a clause for how to resolve future disagreements about contributions. Maybe a yearly review meeting.
flatlander_802 is right butt I'd add a mediator clause. If you two can't agree on what's fair, having a neutral third party written into the agreement saves you from a stalemate.
What does the product development partner want? Have they expressed any expectation of equal profits regardless of hours?
They've said they assumed 50/50 profits because ownership is 50/50. They didn't seem open to a salary structure. That's where we got stuck.
If they're not open to a salary structure then you have a bigger problem. You either accept the imbalance or you restructure ownership. Neither is easy.
Are they open to a hybrid? Like a lower salary for your extra hours plus a smaller profit split adjustment? Might be a middle ground.
Also worth checking if you can even amend the operating agreement without their consent. Vermont default is majority vote unless otherwise specified. With two members that might mean you need unanimous consent.
Unanimous consent is likely required for amending the operating agreement in a two-member LLC unless the original agreement says otherwise. That's a hurdle.