So my business partner and I formed an LLC a little over a year ago. He put up a chunk of the startup capital and is on the paperwork as a member, but he has a full-time job and basically never touches anything day-to-day. I'm the one opening, closing, dealing with customers, payroll, the whole thing. We split profits 50/50 like we agreed, but lately I'm feeling weird about it. Am I being unreasonable for thinking the arrangement should change? I don't want to blow up the relationship but it's starting to eat at me.
My LLC has two owners but only one handles daily operations
not unreasonable at all. sweat equity is real. but you signed the operating agreement so check what that thing actually says before you open your mouth about changing splits. might be a whole amendment process.
How long you been running like this? A year of doing everything solo while splitting 50/50 would make anynoe bitter.
lol classic. the guy who "put up capital" and dips is every silent partner story ever. he's gonna be real surprised when you ask to renegotiate.
I'd separate two things. One is compensation for the work — a salary or draww for the managing member before profit split. Two is the profit split itself. Most people conflate them and then the conversation becomes emotional instead of just numbers. If he's not working, he shouldn't be drawing wages, but he's still a member entitled to his share unless the agreement says otherwise. A lot of small LLCs do a managing-member salary plus equal distribution, which might feel fairer to you without gutting his ownership.
this. though I'll add — if there's no salary clause in the agreement, adding one needs his buy-in anyway. so you're having the talk either way.
Does he even know how much you do? Some absentee owners genuinely have no idea until a number gets put in front of them.
He knows roughly but I don't think he's ever seen the actual hours. I pull probably 55-60 a week. I've never laid it out for him in dollar terms.
Then do that first. Track a month, show him what your time is worth at market rate, and the 50/50 suddenly looks pretty lopsided. Numbers argue better than feelings.
Counterpoint — he took the risk with his capital. If the business had flopped, he'd have eaten the loss same as you. Silent capital isn't nothing. That said, a manager's salary on top is normal and doesn't diminish that.
the risk thing is fair for the first stretch, but a year in the business is presumably running. capital risk shrinks, labor keeps going. that imbalance only grows.
honestly just be glad you're not the guy who put up capital AND the other guy. plenty of threads on here where the working partner quits and takes the customer list with him. thzt's your real leverage by the way.
Worth checking whether your state requires member consent for anything beyond ordinary operations,and get any agreement change in writing. Handshake renegotiations are how people end up in exactly this thread two years from now.
Appreciate the angles. The salary-before-split idea is the one I hadn't really considered separately. I'm going to pull a month of hours and put together a real proposal before we talk.