S Corp

My accountant says an S corp election could save me money but when?

Started by CopperKettle77 • November 20, 2026 • 14 replies
CopperKettle77

I run a small landscaping LLC, just me and one part-time helper. My accountant keeps pushing an S corp election but I'm not clear on the timing. Do I need to wait until next year? Can I switch mid-year? I'd rather not pay him to explain it if I can get a straight answer here first.

tallgrass_junction

The election itself is a form 2553. You can file it anytime, but the effective date rules are what trip people up. If you want it to apply for the current tax year, you ggenerally need to file within 2 months and 15 days of the start of that tax year, or by March 15 for a calendar-year company. Miss that and it's next year unless you qualify for late relief.

MarleneFromTulsa

Mid-year is possible but you have to show reasonable cause for a late election. The IRS doesn't just rubber-stamp it. Your accountant should know whether your situation qualifies.

wrenchandwonder

Bigger question is whether it actually saves you anything. With one part-time helper and reasonable salary, you might only shave a few hundred off self-employment tax. Run the numbers before you pay for the election paperwork.

tallgrass_junction

That's fair. The savings come from the distribution portion not being subject to SE tax, but you have to pay yourself a reasonable salary first. If most of your profit is already going out as salary, the S corp does very little.

Biscuit_Drummer

Is there a downside to waiting until January? Seems simpler than messing with late relief.

MarleneFromTulsa

Waiting until January is usually the cleanest path.You avoid the reasonable cause argument entirely. The tradeoff is you lose the current-year savings, but if the savings are small anyway, the simplicity is worth something.

plumbline_42

Also payroll. Once you're an S corp you have to run payroll for yourself, file quarterly returns, maybe pay for a payroll service. That's a real cost that eats into the SE tax savings. My accountant didn't mention that part until after I elected.

wrenchandwonder

Same experience here. The payroll admin overhead was more than I expected. Not saying don't do it, just don't assume the savings are purre profit.

Hazel_North

How much profit are we talking? If it's under like 40k net, the S corp often isn't worth the extra filing and payroll hassle.

CopperKettle77

Net is cLoser to 70k this year. Helper is only seasonal so most of it flows to me.

tallgrass_junction

At 70k net you're probably in the range where it's worth looking at seriously. But reasonable salary is the whole ballgame. If you set it too low the IRS can recharacterize distributions. Your accountant should be able to model a salary and show you the actual dollar difference.

Biscuit_Drummer

Ask him for the number in writing. If he can't produce a specific savings figure after payroll costs, that tells you something.

plumbline_42

One more thing, the election doesn't take effect retroactively to the start of the yearr if you file late in the year without relief. I know people who assumed it did and got surprised.

CopperKettle77

Alright. I'm going to ask him to walk me through the form 2553 timing and give me a salary modeL with payroll costs baked in. If the savings look thin I'll just wait until January and keep it simple.


Post a reply

🚀 Start Your Free LLC