So I run a small e-commerce shop from my garage in Ohio. Last year I started getting orders from Pennsylvania and thought I might need to register there for sales tax. I asked my accountant about it and he said it wasn't worth the hassle given my volume. He said to just keep things simple and stay registered only in Ohio. Now I'm second-guessing because a buddy told me he registered in three states last year. I don't want to get hit with penalties later. Anyone else been told the same thing?
My accountant convinced me not to register out of state
I'm not a tax pro, but the rules changed a few years back. It used to be that you only needed to register where you had a physical presence. Now it's more about economic nexus—how much you sell into a state. Your accountant probably looked at your revenue and decided you don't hit any thresholds yet. But it's worth asking him specifically about economic nexus in Pennsylvania.
Your buddy might be selling way more than you, or he might be in a different situation. Registering in multiple states can be a lot of paperwork and fees. I wouldn't just copy what someone else is doing.
How much do you sell into PA annually? If it's under $100k and fewer than 200 transactions, you likely don't have nexus there. That's the threshold most states use now. But you should double-check Pennsylvania's specific rules. I found their revenue department website pretty clear when I looked into it for my own shop.
This is why I just use a marketplace that handles all the tax stuff for me. Less headache.
Marketplaces only handle tax for sales made through them. If you sell on your own site too, you're still on the hook for those.
I was in a similar spot a couple years ago. My accountant said the same thing—stay put unless you cross the threshold. I kept an eye on my numbers and once I got close to $100k in one state, I registered. It's not that scary once you do it, but I get wanting to avoid it if you don't have to.
Also, registration isn't the only cost. You've got filing fees, possibly annual reports, and the time to file returns. If you're just dipping your toe in, it might not be worth it. But i'd get a second opinion if you're really unsure.
One more thing—some states have a "safe harbor" for small sellers. Pennsylvania might not require registration until you exceed the threshold. But once you do, you have to register. So you're not off the hook forever.
Thanks for the input. I looked up PA's threshold and I'm well under it for now. I'll keep tracking my sales and revisit if I get close. I'll also ask my accountant to explain the economic nexus rule more clearly so I understand the reasoning.