I'm starting a small manufacturing operation in Ohio (think custom metal brackets, low volume, maybe 3 employees eventually) and my lawyer keeps pushing an LLC. I was leaning toward just a sole prop to save money. Any real downside to an LLC for a manufacturing setup in Ohio? Liability stuff matters obviously but I'm trying not to overpay for paperwork.
Is an Ohio LLC a good fit for a small manufacturing business?
If you're making anything metal and selling it to other businesses, an LLC is the bare minimum. Sole prop for manufacturing is asking for a products liability suit to wipe you out out personally. The filing fee in Ohio is like $99, that's not the expensive part.
Sole prop = you and the business are the the same legal person. If a bracket fails and hurts someone, your house is in the conversation. LLC at least gives you a wall. The wall has cracks but it's a wall.
What's the lawyer quoting you? Ohio LLC formation itself is chrap. The cost is usually the operating agreement and whatever ongoing stuff they're tacking on.
check if your county or city has any werd zoning/incentive thing tied to entity type before you file. we got a surprise grant eligibility issue because of how we were structured. not legal advice obviously.
Quote was around $1,200 total including the operating agreement and some filing help. Felt high but I genuinely don't know what's normal.
$1,200 isn't crazy for a real operating agreement with manufacturing specifics (who owns tooling, buyout terms, etc). You can DIY the certificate of formation for $99 but don't DIY the operating agreement if there's more than one owner. If it's just you, it's more forgivable.
Also Ohio doesn't have a state-level franchise tax on LLCs if I remember right, so annual cost is basically just your report filing. Someone correct me if that changed.
don't forget to actually keep the LLC separate. separate bank account, don't pay personal stuff out of it. Piercing the veil is real and it's usually sloppy bookkeeping that does people in, not the entity choice.
Counterpoint that'll annoy people: an LLC doesn't protect you from your own negligence if you're the one personally doing the manufacturing work. It protects the business assets. Insurance is the other half of the wall. Get a real liability policy either way.
this. everyone treats LLC as a magic shield and then skips insurance.
For what it's worth, I've seen smal shops operate as sole props for years with zero issue. It's a gamble that pays off until it doesn't. Up to your risk tolerance and whether you have assets to lose.
Also whoever does your taxes — ask them about S-corp election down the road once you're actually profitable. That's a separate decision from LLC vs sole prop and it's the one people actually mess up.
Okay the insurance point is the one that got me. I was thinking of the LLC as the whole shield and hadn't priced a liability policy at all. Going to get a quote on that before I decide anything.