I run three small online stores: one sells handmade candles, another does custom phone cases, and a third is a subscription box for dog treats. Right now they're all under my personal name and it's a mess. I want to put everything under one LLC to simplify taxes and banking. Is that allowed, or do I need separate LLCs for each brand? I'm in the US if that matters.
I want one LLC to own several unrelated brands
One LLC can own multiple brands as long as they're not legally separate entities. You'd just operate them as divisions or DBAs under the same LLC. The main thing is keeping clear records so you can show which revenue belongs to which brand if you ever get audited
Liability is the bigger issue. If one brand gets sued, the LLC's assets are exposed. Separate LLCs would shield each brand from the others' risks. For candles and phone cases, that might be overkill, but if the dog treat subscription has any health-related claims, you might want that one separate.
That's a good point about liability. I hadn't thought about the dog treats being a higher risk. Would a holding company with separate LLCs under it be a reasonable middle ground, or is that too complex for a small operation?
Holding company plus subs is standard but adds paperwork and cost. If you're doing a few hundred thousand in revenue, it might be worth it. Otherwise, one LLC with strong insurance might be simpler.
Also check your state's rules on DBAs. Some states require separate registrations for each trade name under the same LLC. And your bank might want separate accounts for each brand anyway to keep things clean.
Taxes don't care about brands. The LLC files as one entity. You You can track brands internally but it's all one return unless you elect S-corp or something. So from a tax simplification standpoint, one LLC is easier.
Right,but if you ever want to sell one brand, having it in a separate LLC makes the sale much cleaner. You can just sell the membership interest instead of trying to carve out assets. That's a factor if you plan to exit.
I'm not planning to sell anytime soon, but it's good to know. I think I'll start with one LLC and separate bank accounts, then revisit if the dog treat side grows. Thanks for the input, though.
That sounds sensible. Just make sure your operating agreement mentions all the brands or allows for adding them. Some banks and payment processors ask for that.
And don't forget to update your insurance policy to cover all three. A general liability policy might not automatically include the subscription boox if it's considered a different class of business.