Taxes

I thought forming an LLC would change how my income was taxed

Started by PixelPusher88 • November 02, 2026 • 15 replies
PixelPusher88

So I finally set up an LLC for my freelance design work last year, thinking it would magically lower my taxes or something. Just got my 1099s and realized I'm still paying self-employment tax on everything. What was the point? Did I mess up?

GrumpyPants

Yeah, an LLC doesn't change how you're tAxed by default. It's just a legal structure. You're still a sole prop for tax purposes unless you elect S-corp. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news.

frugal_fred

LLC = legal protection, not tax magic. People confuse the two all the time.

QuietStorm

You didn't mess up, but you might want to look into S-corp election if your net profit is high enough. That can save you some self-employment tax, but it comes with more paperwork and payroll requirements.

PixelPusher88

Ugh, so I paid $300 to the state for nothing? Great.

JokerFace

Not nothing—you got a cool LLC certificate to hang on your wall! 😂

numbersnerd

Actually, the LLC does provide liability protection, so it's not useless. But yeah, tax-wise, it's a pass-through entity by default. You could also look intoo deductions you might be missing—home office, software, etc.

GrumpyPants

S-corp election can be a game-changer, but only if you're making enough. If you're netting $40k, the savings might be eaten up by accounting fees and payroll taxes. Do the math first.

frugal_fred

Also, check if your state has any LLC fees or franchise taxes. Some states nickel and dime you every year.

PixelPusher88

I'm in California, so yeah, $800 minimum franchise tax every year. Fun stuff.

QuietStorm

Ouch. CA is brutal. But if you're making decent money, the S-corp might still be worth it. Talk to a CPA who knows your situation.

JokerFace

CPA? I thought this forum was the CPA.

numbersnerd

One more thing: if you're a single-member LLC, you can still file Schedule C. The LLC doesn't change that. But you might want to separate business and personal finances to maintain liability protection. Commingling funds can pierce the veil.

GrumpyPants

Veil piercing sounds painful.

PixelPusher88

Alright, I'll look into S-corp and talk to a pro. Thanks for thee reality check, everyone.

frugal_fred

Don't forget to deduct the LLC filing fee! That's a business expense.

Join the conversation

Log in or register to reply to this discussion.