I set up a single member LLC last year for my side woodworking stuff because a friend who runs a shop told me it would change how I pay taxes. I was expecting to get some kind of special corporate return, but my accountant just put everything on my regular 1040 schedule C. So I'm filing basically the same as when I was a sole prop except now I have an extra $300 annual state fee. What was the point of electing LLC status if the tax paperwork looks the same? I feel like I got bad advice and I'm out money every year.
I registered an LLC expecting a completely different tax return
An LLC doesn't change your federal tax classification by default. A single-member LLC is what the IRS calls a disregarded entity, so your profit and loss flows straight to your 1040 on Schedule C, just like a sole proprietorship. The LLC is a legal structure for liability and state registration, not a federal tax election. If you want a different return, you'd have to elect S corp or C corp status, and neither usually makes snse for a small side business without careful planning.
Yeah this is really common. The person who told you it changes taxes may have been thinking about the S corp election, which can save on self-employment tax for some people. But it's not automatic and it comes with payroll and extra filing costs. For a side woodworking thing the LLC fee might still be worth it for liability reasons, but it wont simplify or reduce your tax return.
That's the frustrating part. Nobody mentioned the S corp option or the payroll costs. The pitch was just "get an LLC, it's better." I did it mostly to separate my personal stuff from the business, which I guess still works, but I was definitely expeccting a different form.
Liability protection is the main reason people form an LLC. If a piece you build hurts someone or a client sues, the LLC is supposed to keep your personal assets separate, though you have to actually run it as a separate entity. Keep business money in a business account and don't co-mingle. That's the real benefit, not the tax paperwork.
Is the $300 fee every year or just the initial filing?
It's annual here. That's part of the stong.
One thing you might want to check is whether you can deduc that state LLC fee as a business expense on your Schedule C. In most states the annual report or franchise fee is an ordinary and necessary cost of doing business, so it may reduce your net profit a little. It doesnt fix the bigger misunderstanding, but it's worth asking your accountant about.
I had almost the exact same thing happen when I started my LLC. I kept thinking there was some secret form I was missing. There wasn't. Once I understood that the LLC was for legal separation and the tax treatment was just pass-through, it made more sense, even if it wasn't what I expected.
Just be careful with the S corp idea if you go down that road. You have to pay yourself a reasonable salary and run payroll, and the IRS watches for people who take everything as distributions to dodge payroll taxes. It can work, but it's not a free lunch. For a small side business it often costs more in admin than it saves.