I live in one state but want to form my LLC elsewhere , specifically, I'm in California but want to form in Wyoming or Delaware for privacy and tax reasons. I run an online consulting business with no physical office. What are the real downsides? I keep hearing about foreign qualification but don't fully understand it.
I live in one state but want to form my LLC elsewhere
Foreign qualification means registering your out-of-state LLC to do business in California. Since you live and work from CA, you almost certainly have to register there anywway. So you you'd pay Wyoming/Delaware fees plus California's $800 minimum franchise tax and registration costs. The privacy benefit is minimal if you're the only member because California requires you to list managers/members on its own filings.
This. Also, if you're the only member, Wyoming won't give you meaningful privacy unless you use a registered agent and nominee, which adds cost and complexity. And California can still tax you on income earned there. So you're basically paying double.
Wait, is the $800 franchise tax due even if the LLC makes no money? I thought it was only if you operate in CA tbh.
Yes, it's due annually regardless of income once you're registered or doing business in CA. First year is waived for new LLCs, but after that it's $800 minimum. If you're forming out of state to save money, it rarely works for a solo consultant living in CA.
i looked into this a few years ago. The main legitimate reasons for out-of-state formation are venture capital requirements (Delaware) or if you truly operate in multiple states. For a one-person online business, the consensus seems to be: form where you live. Simpler, cheaper, less paperwork.
What about privacy? I've heard Wyoming doesn't require member names on the formation documents. That could be a reason.
That's true, but you still have to provide your name to the registered agent (who is oftten a commercial service). And if you're doing business in CA, your CA registration will list you. So the privacy is mostly from casual public searches, not from the government or anyone with legal access. Not worth the extra cost for most people.
I'd also consider the annual report fees. Wyoming is $60 minimum, Delaware has a $300 franchise tax. Plus you need a registered agent in that state. Thats another $50-100/year. Meanwhile California charges $800. If you're set on it, talk to a CPA who knows both states. But I agree with the others—probably not worth it.