So I've had this idea bouncing around for a while, a niche subscription box for eco-friendly pet supplies, and I keep reading that I should 'protect myself' with an LLC. But I have literally zero customers, no revenue, and I haven't even launched a website yet. Is it worth the ~$100-500 to form an LLC now, or should I wait until I have some actual traction? I don't want to waste money on something I might abandon, but I also don't want to be stupid about liability. Thoughts?
I have a business idea but zero customers, should I form an LLC?
If you have no customers, you have no liability. An LLC protects you from lawsuits related to your business activities. Right now, your business activities are... thinking. Save the money. Get one customer first, then worry about legal structure.
Hard disagree.Forming the LLC early can help with credibility if you're trying to get suppliers or a domain name. Also, in some states the filing fees are super low. But for a subscription box with literally zero traction? I'd wait. You can always form one later.
What state are you in? That makes a huge difference. CA is $800/year minimum franchise tax just to exist. Wyoming is like $60. If you're in CA, definitely don't form an LLC until you have revenue.
I formed an LLC before I had a single sale. It cost me $150 and maybe 30 minutes of paperwork. The peace of mind was worth it for me, but I know others think that's dumb. Honestly, it's a personal risk tolerance thing. Do you plan to sell products that could hurt someone? If yes, LLC sooner. If it's just digital stuff, maybe wait.
Eco-friendly pet supplies? Like what, bamboo chew toys? Because my dog destroys everything in 5 minutes. Good luck with the 'eco-friendly' part surviving that.
Also, are you planning to raise money? Investors usually want an LLC or C-corp. But if you're bootstrapping, forget it for now.
OP here. No investors, definitely bootstrapping. I'm in Texas, so filing is $300. I don't plan on selling anything that could hurt anyone—it's just pet toys and treats from small suppliers. The main appeal is just having the name secured and feeling 'official.' But $300 is a lot when I haven't sold a single box.
You can secure the name with a DBA (assumed Name) for like $25 in most counties. That gives you the 'official' feeling without the LLC fees. Then upgrade to LLC when you actually have money coming in.
This is the answer. DBA now, LLC later. Don't let the internet convince you that you need a full legal entity to test an idea. Most successful small businesses started as sole props tbh.
Side note: if you're sourcing from small suppliers, some of them might require you to have an LLC or at least a business license to open wholesale accounts. Might be wort asking before you decide.
Or just dropship and call it a day. Kidding. Sort of.
Thanks everyone. I think I'll do the DBA route first and revisit the LLC once I have at least 10 recurring subscribers. If anyone has a good resource for Texas DBA filings, I'm all ears.