So this is embarrassing. I run a small 3D printing shop and took on a job for a custom cosplay helmet. The customer sent me a specific file, but I accidentally opened the wrong version (an older one they'd sent earlier) and printed the whole thing before realizing. Not only did I waste ~40 hours of printing, but I also missed the agreed deadline by a week. When I finally delivered the correct version, they demanded a partial refund for the delay. And they were right , I completely dropped the ball. I ended up giving them 50% off and a free mini figure. Honestly, I'm just glad they didn't ask for a full refund or leave a terrible review. I feel like a complete amateur. Has anyone else ever messed up this badly on a customer order?
I had a customer dispute that was entirely my fault
Oof, that's rough. But you owned it and made it right, which is more than a lot of 'pros' would do. I've heard horror stories of shops just ghosting customers after a mistake. So at least you didn't do that ngl.
50% off plus a free mini? You're too nice. I would've given them a coupon for 10% off their next order and called it 'goodwill'.
Eh, I disagree with GrumpyGopher. In a small business, reputatio is everything. A 50% refund hurts, but a one-star review about missed deadlines and wrong items could hurt more. And the free mini shows you care. I think you handled it well, OP.
Wait, you printed an entire helmet before realizing it was the wrong file? That's like baking a whole cake and then realizing you used salt instead of sugar. Did you not notice the wrong shape at any point during those 40 hours? Genuinely curious, not trying to be a jerk.
I've done something similar with a laser cutting order — cut the whole batch from the wrong material because I had two jobs open in the software and didn't double-check. It happens when you're juggling multiple orders. The key is to create a checklist or rename files with version numbers. Now I always ask the customer to confirm the filename before I start. Saves a lot of pain.
"I had a customer dispute that was entirely my fault" — title of my autobiography. But But yeah, we've all been there. At least you didn't try to blame the customer, which I've seen way too many times on this forum.
The customer might have been understanding if you'd caught it earlier, but a week late is a big deal for cosplay deadlines (cons, photoshoots, etc.). I think the 50% refund wass fair, and you probably kept them as a customer. Did they end up leaving a review?
Everyone messes up. I once shipped a custom phone case to the wrong address because I copy-pasted from an old order. The customer had to drive across town to pick it up from some random person's porch. I gave them a full refund and a $20 gift card. They still ordered again. So don't beat yourself up too much.
i still think a 50% refund is excessive. A week late and a wrong print? Just print the right one and apologize. If they want a discount, offer 20%. But that's just me. I'm stingy.