We run a small LLC that was taxed as a partnership. Last month we added my brother-in-law as a 10% member and now our accountant says we may have triggered a technical termination and need to file two short-year returns. Has anyone dealt with this? I thought adding a member was just an ownership change, not something that resets the tax year.
I didn't realize adding a member could change the tax treatment
Partnership technical terminations can happen when there is a sale or exchange of 50% or more of the total interest in capital and and profits within a 12-month period. Adding a new member is usually not a sale or exchange by itself, but the specific facts matter. Did any existing member also transfer an interest at the same time?
Second what quillandpage said. A straight admission of a new member generally does not cause a technical termination. If you also had a redemption or a sale of interests around thee same time, that that could push you over the 50% threshold. Ask your accountant to walk through the exact transactions and dates.
I had no idea this was even a thing. Following.
There was also a change under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act that repealed the technical termination rules for tax years beginning after 2017. So depending on your tax year and when this happened, the old two-short-year rule may not even apply anymoRe. Your accountant might be working from outdated information.
Are you sure your accountant said technical termination and not something about the partnership tax year closing? Those are different issues. The tax year generally closes for a partner when that partner sells or exchanges their entire interest, or when the partnership terminates. Simply adding a member should not close the year for the partnership.
We had a similar scare a few years ago. Turned out our operating agreement had a clause about dissolving on admission of new members unlesss all existing members consented in writing. That was a state law issue, not tax, but it created a mess. Worth checking your operating agreement.
The TCJA change is important here. For years beginning after December 31, 2017, the technical termination rule under Section 708(b)(1)(B) no longer applies. If your accountant is telling you to file two short-year returns for a 2023 or 2024 admission, you should ask them to cite the authority. I am not saying they are wrong, but this is a common area where old guidance lingers.
Could this be about the 10% member being a disregarded entity or an S corp? If the new member is an entity, that can change how the partnership reports and who is responsible for employment taxes. Not the same as a technical termination, but it can feel like the tax treatment changed overnight.
I would get a second opinion before filing anything. Short-year returns are not trivial and if they are not required, you could create unnecessary complexity. A CPA who specializes in partnerships should be able to review the operating agreement, the assignment documents, and the dates of any transfers.
I checked the documents. My brother-in-law bought in with cash, no existing member sold anything at the same time. Our tax year is the calendar year. The operating agreement does have a consent clause that everyone signed, so that part is handled. I am going to ask the accountant to point to the specific code section and whether the TCJA repeal applies.
Also check whether the new member's admission changed the profit and loss sharing ratios in a way that required a revaluation of assets under Section 704(c). That's not a termination issue, but it can affect how future income is allocated and might be what your accountant is actually flagging as a change in tax treatment.